Does publication in top-tier journals affect reviewer behavior?

Does publication in top-tier journals affect reviewer behavior?

Show other versions (1)

We show that when ecologists act as reviewers their reported rejection rates recommended for manuscripts increases with their publication frequency in high impact factor journals. Rejection rate however does not relate to reviewer age. These results indicate that the likelihood of getting a paper ac...

Deskribapen osoa

Xehetasun bibliografikoak
Egile Nagusiak:	Aarssen, L, Lortie, C, Budden, A, Koricheva, J, Leimu, R, Tregenza, T
Formatua:	Journal article
Hizkuntza:	English
Argitaratua:	Public Library of Science 2009
Gaiak:	Biology

Antzeko izenburuak

Does publication in top-tier journals affect reviewer behavior?
nork: Aarssen, L, et al.
Argitaratua: (2009)

Does double-blind review favor female authors? Reply
nork: Budden, A, et al.
Argitaratua: (2008)

Does it pay to have a "bigwig" as a co-author?
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2008)

Publication bias and merit in ecology
nork: Lortie, C, et al.
Argitaratua: (2007)

Double-blind review favours increased representation of female authors.
nork: Budden, A, et al.
Argitaratua: (2008)

Response to Webb et al.: Double-blind review: accept with minor revisions
nork: Budden, A, et al.
Argitaratua: (2008)

To Name or Not to Name: The Effect of Changing Author Gender on Peer Review
nork: Borsuk, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2009)

How big are bigwigs?: a reply to Havens
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2008)

Response to Whittaker: challenges in testing for gender bias
nork: Budden, A, et al.
Argitaratua: (2008)

Systematic variation in reviewer practice according to country and gender in the field of ecology and evolution.
nork: Grod, O, et al.
Argitaratua: (2008)

Do citations and impact factors relate to the real numbers in publications? A case study of citation rates, impact, and effect sizes in ecology and evolutionary biology
nork: Lortie, C, et al.
Argitaratua: (2012)

Do citations and impact factors relate to the real numbers in publications? A case study of citation rates, impact, and effect sizes in ecology and evolutionary biology.
nork: Lortie, C, et al.
Argitaratua: (2013)

The influence of author gender, national language and number of authors on citation rate in ecology
nork: Borsuk, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2009)

Does scientific collaboration increase the impact of ecological articles?
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2005)

Cumulative meta-analysis: a new tool for detection of temporal trends and publication bias in ecology.
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2004)

Does top managers experience affect firms capital structure?
nork: Tunde, Matemilola Bolaji, et al.
Argitaratua: (2018)

A meta-analysis of tradeoffs between plant tolerance and resistance to herbivores: combining the evidence from ecological and agricultural studies
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2012)

A meta-analysis of genetic correlations between plant resistances to multiple enemies.
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2006)

What determines the citation frequency of ecological papers?
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2005)

Logical and methodological issues affecting genetic studies of humans reported in top neuroscience journals
nork: Grabitz, CR, et al.
Argitaratua: (2017)

Journal of biological sciences /
nork: Ozaslan, Mehmet, et al.
Argitaratua: (2008)

NEC FUTURE Tier I Scoping Process: Public Comment
nork: Sussman, Joseph M., et al.
Argitaratua: (2016)

The two-tier problem
nork: Wilkinson, D
Argitaratua: (2024)

Physics for higher tier /
nork: 311377 Pople, Stephen
Argitaratua: (2001)

Journal update monthly top five
nork: Glover, SJ, et al.
Argitaratua: (2023)

Does religious fasting affect cognitive performance?
nork: Mohd Yasin, Wardah, et al.
Argitaratua: (2013)

Does open data need journalism?
nork: Stoneman, J
Argitaratua: (2015)

A review on third generation bioethanol feedstock: Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
nork: Siti Azmah Jambo, et al.
Argitaratua: (2016)

Evaluating and managing the tiers of R&D
Argitaratua: (2003)

The Changing Role of the Regional Tier of the NHS
nork: Dopson, S, et al.
Argitaratua: (1997)

Target science : chemistry foundation tier /
nork: O'Brien, Pat
Argitaratua: (2001)

MBA in a day : what you would learn at top-tier business schools (if you only had the time!) /
nork: Stralser, Steven, 1945-
Argitaratua: (2004)

UMP journal tops automotive engineering ranking again
nork: UMP, PNC
Argitaratua: (2016)

How general are positive relationships between plant population size, fitness and genetic variation?
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2006)

Does board size matters? New evidence from a two-tier board system / Salim Darmadi
nork: Darmadi, Salim
Argitaratua: (2014)

Between-population outbreeding affects plant defence.
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2010)

Between-population outbreeding affects plant defence
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2010)

Between-population outbreeding affects plant defence.
nork: Leimu, R, et al.
Argitaratua: (2010)

Review of 'Altruistically inclined?: the behavioral sciences, evolutionary theory, and the origins of reciprocity'
nork: Curry, O
Argitaratua: (2003)

A comparison between four-tier framework and three-tier framework for online applications of 3D GIS visualization
nork: Che Mat, Ruzinoor, et al.
Argitaratua: (2013)