Achieving a mass-scale transition to clean cooking in India to improve public health
<p>This research provides policy-relevant insights into how a mass-scale, equitable transition to the use of Advanced Biomass (cook) Stoves (ABSs) can be achieved in India, with the aim of improving public health, especially for women and children. The research uses socio-technical systems to...
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Other Authors: | |
| Format: | Thesis |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
2012
|
| Subjects: |
| _version_ | 1826316455445004288 |
|---|---|
| author | Mann, P |
| author2 | Boardman, B |
| author_facet | Boardman, B Mann, P |
| author_sort | Mann, P |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | <p>This research provides policy-relevant insights into how a mass-scale, equitable transition to the use of Advanced Biomass (cook) Stoves (ABSs) can be achieved in India, with the aim of improving public health, especially for women and children. The research uses socio-technical systems to provide a characterisation of transition processes, and governance to explain issues of power influencing transition. A review of previous government cook-stove programmes in India and China highlights governance shortcomings in the former, in particular a lack of functional links between layers of administration and poor engagement with community institutions and cooks. Primary data from West Bengal and Karnataka highlighted sophisticated, skilful, flexible and culturally context specific cooking practices. Reasons for apparent low demand for improved stoves, characterised as lock-in, are found to include a combination of risk aversion and habits, lack of affordability, low awareness of the health consequences, as well as a mis-match between the normative priorities of policy makers – currently health- and those of cooks. It is found that the majority of polluting emissions within households - as well as greenhouse gases - from cooking derive from poorer households. A sectoral carbon offset strategy is proposed as a means of funding subsidies for ABSs and programme support measures. Several large corporations have invested significant sums in technology development, community outreach and dissemination, resulting in sales of over 600,000 ABSs. Reasons for their involvement appear mixed. Their market-based activities have generally not reached poor households and there are questions about their ability to build viable businesses in this highly dispersed and heterogeneous sector. A fundamental dichotomy is highlighted between large, centralised cooking programmes and the diverse, complex and changing reality of cooking activities, beliefs and behaviours on the ground. The research concludes that functional multi-level and multi-actor governance structures would be required to achieve a mass-scale transition to clean cooking using ABSs, with a lead role for the public sector. A key component of future success will involve building structures that ensure the agency of cooks and account for their socio-cultural cooking practices in the processes of technology and programme design and implementation.</p> |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-06T21:22:07Z |
| format | Thesis |
| id | oxford-uuid:41ca7cfc-c3e2-43af-93ae-aab09f4e3178 |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-09T03:45:26Z |
| publishDate | 2012 |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:41ca7cfc-c3e2-43af-93ae-aab09f4e31782024-12-07T17:11:51ZAchieving a mass-scale transition to clean cooking in India to improve public healthThesishttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_db06uuid:41ca7cfc-c3e2-43af-93ae-aab09f4e3178Environmental changeTechnologies of politics and ecologyEntrepreneurshipGovernance and ethicsPolitical economy of markets and statesAsiaHealth and health policySocial anthropologyHuman developmentEthnographic practicesClimate systems and policyEnglishOxford University Research Archive - Valet2012Mann, PBoardman, BLiverman, D<p>This research provides policy-relevant insights into how a mass-scale, equitable transition to the use of Advanced Biomass (cook) Stoves (ABSs) can be achieved in India, with the aim of improving public health, especially for women and children. The research uses socio-technical systems to provide a characterisation of transition processes, and governance to explain issues of power influencing transition. A review of previous government cook-stove programmes in India and China highlights governance shortcomings in the former, in particular a lack of functional links between layers of administration and poor engagement with community institutions and cooks. Primary data from West Bengal and Karnataka highlighted sophisticated, skilful, flexible and culturally context specific cooking practices. Reasons for apparent low demand for improved stoves, characterised as lock-in, are found to include a combination of risk aversion and habits, lack of affordability, low awareness of the health consequences, as well as a mis-match between the normative priorities of policy makers – currently health- and those of cooks. It is found that the majority of polluting emissions within households - as well as greenhouse gases - from cooking derive from poorer households. A sectoral carbon offset strategy is proposed as a means of funding subsidies for ABSs and programme support measures. Several large corporations have invested significant sums in technology development, community outreach and dissemination, resulting in sales of over 600,000 ABSs. Reasons for their involvement appear mixed. Their market-based activities have generally not reached poor households and there are questions about their ability to build viable businesses in this highly dispersed and heterogeneous sector. A fundamental dichotomy is highlighted between large, centralised cooking programmes and the diverse, complex and changing reality of cooking activities, beliefs and behaviours on the ground. The research concludes that functional multi-level and multi-actor governance structures would be required to achieve a mass-scale transition to clean cooking using ABSs, with a lead role for the public sector. A key component of future success will involve building structures that ensure the agency of cooks and account for their socio-cultural cooking practices in the processes of technology and programme design and implementation.</p> |
| spellingShingle | Environmental change Technologies of politics and ecology Entrepreneurship Governance and ethics Political economy of markets and states Asia Health and health policy Social anthropology Human development Ethnographic practices Climate systems and policy Mann, P Achieving a mass-scale transition to clean cooking in India to improve public health |
| title | Achieving a mass-scale transition to clean cooking in India to improve public health |
| title_full | Achieving a mass-scale transition to clean cooking in India to improve public health |
| title_fullStr | Achieving a mass-scale transition to clean cooking in India to improve public health |
| title_full_unstemmed | Achieving a mass-scale transition to clean cooking in India to improve public health |
| title_short | Achieving a mass-scale transition to clean cooking in India to improve public health |
| title_sort | achieving a mass scale transition to clean cooking in india to improve public health |
| topic | Environmental change Technologies of politics and ecology Entrepreneurship Governance and ethics Political economy of markets and states Asia Health and health policy Social anthropology Human development Ethnographic practices Climate systems and policy |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT mannp achievingamassscaletransitiontocleancookinginindiatoimprovepublichealth |