Repeatability of motor and working-memory tasks in healthy older volunteers: assessment at functional MR imaging.

PURPOSE: To prospectively determine the repeatability of functional magnetic resonance (MR) imaging brain activation tasks in a group of healthy older male volunteers. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Local research ethics committee approval and informed consent were obtained. Sixteen men with a mean age of...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Marshall, I, Simonotto, E, Deary, I, Maclullich, A, Ebmeier, K, Rose, E, Wardlaw, J, Goddard, N, Chappell, F
Format: Journal article
Language:English
Published: 2004
_version_ 1797068880155246592
author Marshall, I
Simonotto, E
Deary, I
Maclullich, A
Ebmeier, K
Rose, E
Wardlaw, J
Goddard, N
Chappell, F
author_facet Marshall, I
Simonotto, E
Deary, I
Maclullich, A
Ebmeier, K
Rose, E
Wardlaw, J
Goddard, N
Chappell, F
author_sort Marshall, I
collection OXFORD
description PURPOSE: To prospectively determine the repeatability of functional magnetic resonance (MR) imaging brain activation tasks in a group of healthy older male volunteers. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Local research ethics committee approval and informed consent were obtained. Sixteen men with a mean age of 69 years +/- 3 (standard deviation) performed finger-tapping and N-back (number of screens back) working-memory tasks. Each subject underwent MR imaging three times in weekly intervals. Within-subject task repeatability was analyzed in terms of the number of voxels classified as activated (activation extent), the mean activation amplitude, and (for finger tapping) the center of the mass of the activated region. A repeatability index was calculated to compare test-retest repeatability between subjects and between functional MR imaging tasks. Within-session, between-session, and between-subject variability was assessed by using analysis of variance testing of activation amplitude and extent. RESULTS: Nine of the 16 subjects generated useful data at all three MR imaging-functional task sessions. At single-subject, single-session analysis, cortical activation was identified in most subjects and at most sessions. The centers of the masses of motor cortex activation were highly reproducible (within 3 mm). Patterns of activation were qualitatively repeatable, but there was substantial variability in the amplitudes and extents of activated regions. Within-session coefficients of variation (CVs) for left- versus right-hand and right- versus left-hand finger tapping were, respectively, 65% and 43% for activation amplitude and 75% and 121% for activation extent. The between-session CVs for activation amplitude were similar to the within-session values, whereas between-session CVs for activation extent were much greater than within-session values, up to 206%. CONCLUSION: The generally poor quantitative task repeatability highlights the need for further methodologic developments before much reliance can be placed on functional MR imaging results of single-session experiments.
first_indexed 2024-03-06T22:16:21Z
format Journal article
id oxford-uuid:5383125a-4698-4983-85a3-1303d1c99a51
institution University of Oxford
language English
last_indexed 2024-03-06T22:16:21Z
publishDate 2004
record_format dspace
spelling oxford-uuid:5383125a-4698-4983-85a3-1303d1c99a512022-03-26T16:32:10ZRepeatability of motor and working-memory tasks in healthy older volunteers: assessment at functional MR imaging.Journal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:5383125a-4698-4983-85a3-1303d1c99a51EnglishSymplectic Elements at Oxford2004Marshall, ISimonotto, EDeary, IMaclullich, AEbmeier, KRose, EWardlaw, JGoddard, NChappell, F PURPOSE: To prospectively determine the repeatability of functional magnetic resonance (MR) imaging brain activation tasks in a group of healthy older male volunteers. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Local research ethics committee approval and informed consent were obtained. Sixteen men with a mean age of 69 years +/- 3 (standard deviation) performed finger-tapping and N-back (number of screens back) working-memory tasks. Each subject underwent MR imaging three times in weekly intervals. Within-subject task repeatability was analyzed in terms of the number of voxels classified as activated (activation extent), the mean activation amplitude, and (for finger tapping) the center of the mass of the activated region. A repeatability index was calculated to compare test-retest repeatability between subjects and between functional MR imaging tasks. Within-session, between-session, and between-subject variability was assessed by using analysis of variance testing of activation amplitude and extent. RESULTS: Nine of the 16 subjects generated useful data at all three MR imaging-functional task sessions. At single-subject, single-session analysis, cortical activation was identified in most subjects and at most sessions. The centers of the masses of motor cortex activation were highly reproducible (within 3 mm). Patterns of activation were qualitatively repeatable, but there was substantial variability in the amplitudes and extents of activated regions. Within-session coefficients of variation (CVs) for left- versus right-hand and right- versus left-hand finger tapping were, respectively, 65% and 43% for activation amplitude and 75% and 121% for activation extent. The between-session CVs for activation amplitude were similar to the within-session values, whereas between-session CVs for activation extent were much greater than within-session values, up to 206%. CONCLUSION: The generally poor quantitative task repeatability highlights the need for further methodologic developments before much reliance can be placed on functional MR imaging results of single-session experiments.
spellingShingle Marshall, I
Simonotto, E
Deary, I
Maclullich, A
Ebmeier, K
Rose, E
Wardlaw, J
Goddard, N
Chappell, F
Repeatability of motor and working-memory tasks in healthy older volunteers: assessment at functional MR imaging.
title Repeatability of motor and working-memory tasks in healthy older volunteers: assessment at functional MR imaging.
title_full Repeatability of motor and working-memory tasks in healthy older volunteers: assessment at functional MR imaging.
title_fullStr Repeatability of motor and working-memory tasks in healthy older volunteers: assessment at functional MR imaging.
title_full_unstemmed Repeatability of motor and working-memory tasks in healthy older volunteers: assessment at functional MR imaging.
title_short Repeatability of motor and working-memory tasks in healthy older volunteers: assessment at functional MR imaging.
title_sort repeatability of motor and working memory tasks in healthy older volunteers assessment at functional mr imaging
work_keys_str_mv AT marshalli repeatabilityofmotorandworkingmemorytasksinhealthyoldervolunteersassessmentatfunctionalmrimaging
AT simonottoe repeatabilityofmotorandworkingmemorytasksinhealthyoldervolunteersassessmentatfunctionalmrimaging
AT dearyi repeatabilityofmotorandworkingmemorytasksinhealthyoldervolunteersassessmentatfunctionalmrimaging
AT maclullicha repeatabilityofmotorandworkingmemorytasksinhealthyoldervolunteersassessmentatfunctionalmrimaging
AT ebmeierk repeatabilityofmotorandworkingmemorytasksinhealthyoldervolunteersassessmentatfunctionalmrimaging
AT rosee repeatabilityofmotorandworkingmemorytasksinhealthyoldervolunteersassessmentatfunctionalmrimaging
AT wardlawj repeatabilityofmotorandworkingmemorytasksinhealthyoldervolunteersassessmentatfunctionalmrimaging
AT goddardn repeatabilityofmotorandworkingmemorytasksinhealthyoldervolunteersassessmentatfunctionalmrimaging
AT chappellf repeatabilityofmotorandworkingmemorytasksinhealthyoldervolunteersassessmentatfunctionalmrimaging