Likely health outcomes for untreated acute febrile illness in the tropics in decision and economic models; a Delphi survey.
BACKGROUND: Modelling is widely used to inform decisions about management of malaria and acute febrile illnesses. Most models depend on estimates of the probability that untreated patients with malaria or bacterial illnesses will progress to severe disease or death. However, data on these key parame...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Public Library of Science
2011
|
| _version_ | 1797070020320165888 |
|---|---|
| author | Lubell, Y Staedke, S Greenwood, B Kamya, MR Molyneux, M Newton, P Reyburn, H Snow, R D'Alessandro, U English, M Day, N Kremsner, P Dondorp, A Mbacham, W Dorsey, G Owusu-Agyei, S Maitland, K Krishna, S Newton, C Pasvol, G Taylor, T von Seidlein, L White, N Binka, F Mills, A Whitty, C |
| author_facet | Lubell, Y Staedke, S Greenwood, B Kamya, MR Molyneux, M Newton, P Reyburn, H Snow, R D'Alessandro, U English, M Day, N Kremsner, P Dondorp, A Mbacham, W Dorsey, G Owusu-Agyei, S Maitland, K Krishna, S Newton, C Pasvol, G Taylor, T von Seidlein, L White, N Binka, F Mills, A Whitty, C |
| author_sort | Lubell, Y |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | BACKGROUND: Modelling is widely used to inform decisions about management of malaria and acute febrile illnesses. Most models depend on estimates of the probability that untreated patients with malaria or bacterial illnesses will progress to severe disease or death. However, data on these key parameters are lacking and assumptions are frequently made based on expert opinion. Widely diverse opinions can lead to conflicting outcomes in models they inform. METHODS AND FINDINGS: A Delphi survey was conducted with malaria experts aiming to reach consensus on key parameters for public health and economic models, relating to the outcome of untreated febrile illnesses. Survey questions were stratified by malaria transmission intensity, patient age, and HIV prevalence. The impact of the variability in opinion on decision models is illustrated with a model previously used to assess the cost-effectiveness of malaria rapid diagnostic tests. Some consensus was reached around the probability that patients from higher transmission settings with untreated malaria would progress to severe disease (median 3%, inter-quartile range (IQR) 1-5%), and the probability that a non-malaria illness required antibiotics in areas of low HIV prevalence (median 20%). Children living in low transmission areas were considered to be at higher risk of progressing to severe malaria (median 30%, IQR 10-58%) than those from higher transmission areas (median 13%, IQR 7-30%). Estimates of the probability of dying from severe malaria were high in all settings (medians 60-73%). However, opinions varied widely for most parameters, and did not converge on resurveying. CONCLUSIONS: This study highlights the uncertainty around potential consequences of untreated malaria and bacterial illnesses. The lack of consensus on most parameters, the wide range of estimates, and the impact of variability in estimates on model outputs, demonstrate the importance of sensitivity analysis for decision models employing expert opinion. Results of such models should be interpreted cautiously. The diversity of expert opinion should be recognised when policy options are debated. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-06T22:33:02Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:58e62d3c-f8e5-45c4-b7e7-8d6e960f3cbc |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-06T22:33:02Z |
| publishDate | 2011 |
| publisher | Public Library of Science |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:58e62d3c-f8e5-45c4-b7e7-8d6e960f3cbc2022-03-26T17:06:34ZLikely health outcomes for untreated acute febrile illness in the tropics in decision and economic models; a Delphi survey.Journal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:58e62d3c-f8e5-45c4-b7e7-8d6e960f3cbcEnglishSymplectic Elements at OxfordPublic Library of Science2011Lubell, YStaedke, SGreenwood, BKamya, MRMolyneux, MNewton, PReyburn, HSnow, RD'Alessandro, UEnglish, MDay, NKremsner, PDondorp, AMbacham, WDorsey, GOwusu-Agyei, SMaitland, KKrishna, SNewton, CPasvol, GTaylor, Tvon Seidlein, LWhite, NBinka, FMills, AWhitty, CBACKGROUND: Modelling is widely used to inform decisions about management of malaria and acute febrile illnesses. Most models depend on estimates of the probability that untreated patients with malaria or bacterial illnesses will progress to severe disease or death. However, data on these key parameters are lacking and assumptions are frequently made based on expert opinion. Widely diverse opinions can lead to conflicting outcomes in models they inform. METHODS AND FINDINGS: A Delphi survey was conducted with malaria experts aiming to reach consensus on key parameters for public health and economic models, relating to the outcome of untreated febrile illnesses. Survey questions were stratified by malaria transmission intensity, patient age, and HIV prevalence. The impact of the variability in opinion on decision models is illustrated with a model previously used to assess the cost-effectiveness of malaria rapid diagnostic tests. Some consensus was reached around the probability that patients from higher transmission settings with untreated malaria would progress to severe disease (median 3%, inter-quartile range (IQR) 1-5%), and the probability that a non-malaria illness required antibiotics in areas of low HIV prevalence (median 20%). Children living in low transmission areas were considered to be at higher risk of progressing to severe malaria (median 30%, IQR 10-58%) than those from higher transmission areas (median 13%, IQR 7-30%). Estimates of the probability of dying from severe malaria were high in all settings (medians 60-73%). However, opinions varied widely for most parameters, and did not converge on resurveying. CONCLUSIONS: This study highlights the uncertainty around potential consequences of untreated malaria and bacterial illnesses. The lack of consensus on most parameters, the wide range of estimates, and the impact of variability in estimates on model outputs, demonstrate the importance of sensitivity analysis for decision models employing expert opinion. Results of such models should be interpreted cautiously. The diversity of expert opinion should be recognised when policy options are debated. |
| spellingShingle | Lubell, Y Staedke, S Greenwood, B Kamya, MR Molyneux, M Newton, P Reyburn, H Snow, R D'Alessandro, U English, M Day, N Kremsner, P Dondorp, A Mbacham, W Dorsey, G Owusu-Agyei, S Maitland, K Krishna, S Newton, C Pasvol, G Taylor, T von Seidlein, L White, N Binka, F Mills, A Whitty, C Likely health outcomes for untreated acute febrile illness in the tropics in decision and economic models; a Delphi survey. |
| title | Likely health outcomes for untreated acute febrile illness in the tropics in decision and economic models; a Delphi survey. |
| title_full | Likely health outcomes for untreated acute febrile illness in the tropics in decision and economic models; a Delphi survey. |
| title_fullStr | Likely health outcomes for untreated acute febrile illness in the tropics in decision and economic models; a Delphi survey. |
| title_full_unstemmed | Likely health outcomes for untreated acute febrile illness in the tropics in decision and economic models; a Delphi survey. |
| title_short | Likely health outcomes for untreated acute febrile illness in the tropics in decision and economic models; a Delphi survey. |
| title_sort | likely health outcomes for untreated acute febrile illness in the tropics in decision and economic models a delphi survey |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT lubelly likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT staedkes likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT greenwoodb likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT kamyamr likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT molyneuxm likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT newtonp likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT reyburnh likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT snowr likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT dalessandrou likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT englishm likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT dayn likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT kremsnerp likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT dondorpa likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT mbachamw likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT dorseyg likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT owusuagyeis likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT maitlandk likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT krishnas likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT newtonc likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT pasvolg likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT taylort likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT vonseidleinl likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT whiten likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT binkaf likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT millsa likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey AT whittyc likelyhealthoutcomesforuntreatedacutefebrileillnessinthetropicsindecisionandeconomicmodelsadelphisurvey |