Identifying falsified COVID-19 vaccines by analysing vaccine vial label and excipient profiles using MALDI-ToF mass spectrometry
<p>The rapid development and worldwide distribution of COVID-19 vaccines is a remarkable achievement of biomedical research and logistical implementation. However, these developments are associated with the risk of a surge of substandard and falsified (SF) vaccines, as illustrated by the 184 i...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Springer Nature
2025
|
| _version_ | 1824459086395080704 |
|---|---|
| author | Arman, BY Clarke, R Bharucha, T Gomez Fernandez, L Walsby-Tickle, J Deats, M Mosca, S Lin, Q Banerjee, S Chunekar, S Patil, K Gairola, S Dunachie, S Merchant, H Stokes, R Kuwana, R Maes, A Charrier, J-P Probert, F Caillet, C Matousek, P McCullagh, J Newton, P Zitzmann, N Gangadharan, B |
| author_facet | Arman, BY Clarke, R Bharucha, T Gomez Fernandez, L Walsby-Tickle, J Deats, M Mosca, S Lin, Q Banerjee, S Chunekar, S Patil, K Gairola, S Dunachie, S Merchant, H Stokes, R Kuwana, R Maes, A Charrier, J-P Probert, F Caillet, C Matousek, P McCullagh, J Newton, P Zitzmann, N Gangadharan, B |
| author_sort | Arman, BY |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | <p>The rapid development and worldwide distribution of COVID-19 vaccines is a remarkable achievement of biomedical research and logistical implementation. However, these developments are associated with the risk of a surge of substandard and falsified (SF) vaccines, as illustrated by the 184 incidents with SF and diverted COVID-19 vaccines which have been reported during the pandemic in 48 countries, with a paucity of methods for their detection in supply chains. In this context, matrix-assisted laser desorption ionisation-time of flight (MALDI-ToF) mass spectrometry (MS) is globally available for fast and accurate analysis of bacteria in patient samples, offering a potentially accessible solution to identify SF vaccines. We analysed the COVISHIELD™ COVID-19 vaccine; falsified versions of which were found in India, Myanmar and Uganda. We demonstrate for the first time that analysis of spectra from the vaccine vial label and its adhesive could be used as a novel approach to detect falsified vaccines. Vials tested by this approach could be retained in the supply chain since it is non-invasive. We also assessed whether MALDI-ToF MS could be used to distinguish the COVISHIELD™ vaccine from surrogates of falsified vaccines and the effect of temperature on vaccine stability. Both polysorbate 80 and L-histidine excipients of the genuine vaccine could be detected by the presence of a unique combination of MALDI-ToF MS peaks which allowed us to distinguish between the genuine vaccines and falsified vaccine surrogates. Furthermore, even if a falsified product contained polysorbate 80 at the same concentration as used in the genuine vaccine, the characteristic spectral profile of polysorbate 80 used in genuine products is a reliable internal marker for vaccine authenticity. Our findings demonstrate that MALDI-ToF MS analysis of extracts from vial labels and the vaccine excipients themselves can be used independently to detect falsified vaccines. This approach has the potential to be integrated into the national regulatory standards and WHO’s Prevent, Detect, and Respond strategy as a novel effective tool for detecting falsified vaccines.</p> |
| first_indexed | 2025-02-19T04:36:12Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:59643ac9-d09b-44ed-8e98-30bd2eae17d8 |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2025-02-19T04:36:12Z |
| publishDate | 2025 |
| publisher | Springer Nature |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:59643ac9-d09b-44ed-8e98-30bd2eae17d82025-02-03T09:51:47ZIdentifying falsified COVID-19 vaccines by analysing vaccine vial label and excipient profiles using MALDI-ToF mass spectrometryJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:59643ac9-d09b-44ed-8e98-30bd2eae17d8EnglishSymplectic ElementsSpringer Nature2025Arman, BYClarke, RBharucha, TGomez Fernandez, LWalsby-Tickle, JDeats, MMosca, SLin, QBanerjee, SChunekar, SPatil, KGairola, SDunachie, SMerchant, HStokes, RKuwana, RMaes, ACharrier, J-PProbert, FCaillet, CMatousek, PMcCullagh, JNewton, PZitzmann, NGangadharan, B<p>The rapid development and worldwide distribution of COVID-19 vaccines is a remarkable achievement of biomedical research and logistical implementation. However, these developments are associated with the risk of a surge of substandard and falsified (SF) vaccines, as illustrated by the 184 incidents with SF and diverted COVID-19 vaccines which have been reported during the pandemic in 48 countries, with a paucity of methods for their detection in supply chains. In this context, matrix-assisted laser desorption ionisation-time of flight (MALDI-ToF) mass spectrometry (MS) is globally available for fast and accurate analysis of bacteria in patient samples, offering a potentially accessible solution to identify SF vaccines. We analysed the COVISHIELD™ COVID-19 vaccine; falsified versions of which were found in India, Myanmar and Uganda. We demonstrate for the first time that analysis of spectra from the vaccine vial label and its adhesive could be used as a novel approach to detect falsified vaccines. Vials tested by this approach could be retained in the supply chain since it is non-invasive. We also assessed whether MALDI-ToF MS could be used to distinguish the COVISHIELD™ vaccine from surrogates of falsified vaccines and the effect of temperature on vaccine stability. Both polysorbate 80 and L-histidine excipients of the genuine vaccine could be detected by the presence of a unique combination of MALDI-ToF MS peaks which allowed us to distinguish between the genuine vaccines and falsified vaccine surrogates. Furthermore, even if a falsified product contained polysorbate 80 at the same concentration as used in the genuine vaccine, the characteristic spectral profile of polysorbate 80 used in genuine products is a reliable internal marker for vaccine authenticity. Our findings demonstrate that MALDI-ToF MS analysis of extracts from vial labels and the vaccine excipients themselves can be used independently to detect falsified vaccines. This approach has the potential to be integrated into the national regulatory standards and WHO’s Prevent, Detect, and Respond strategy as a novel effective tool for detecting falsified vaccines.</p> |
| spellingShingle | Arman, BY Clarke, R Bharucha, T Gomez Fernandez, L Walsby-Tickle, J Deats, M Mosca, S Lin, Q Banerjee, S Chunekar, S Patil, K Gairola, S Dunachie, S Merchant, H Stokes, R Kuwana, R Maes, A Charrier, J-P Probert, F Caillet, C Matousek, P McCullagh, J Newton, P Zitzmann, N Gangadharan, B Identifying falsified COVID-19 vaccines by analysing vaccine vial label and excipient profiles using MALDI-ToF mass spectrometry |
| title | Identifying falsified COVID-19 vaccines by analysing vaccine vial label and excipient profiles using MALDI-ToF mass spectrometry |
| title_full | Identifying falsified COVID-19 vaccines by analysing vaccine vial label and excipient profiles using MALDI-ToF mass spectrometry |
| title_fullStr | Identifying falsified COVID-19 vaccines by analysing vaccine vial label and excipient profiles using MALDI-ToF mass spectrometry |
| title_full_unstemmed | Identifying falsified COVID-19 vaccines by analysing vaccine vial label and excipient profiles using MALDI-ToF mass spectrometry |
| title_short | Identifying falsified COVID-19 vaccines by analysing vaccine vial label and excipient profiles using MALDI-ToF mass spectrometry |
| title_sort | identifying falsified covid 19 vaccines by analysing vaccine vial label and excipient profiles using maldi tof mass spectrometry |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT armanby identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT clarker identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT bharuchat identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT gomezfernandezl identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT walsbyticklej identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT deatsm identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT moscas identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT linq identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT banerjees identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT chunekars identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT patilk identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT gairolas identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT dunachies identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT merchanth identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT stokesr identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT kuwanar identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT maesa identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT charrierjp identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT probertf identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT cailletc identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT matousekp identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT mccullaghj identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT newtonp identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT zitzmannn identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry AT gangadharanb identifyingfalsifiedcovid19vaccinesbyanalysingvaccineviallabelandexcipientprofilesusingmalditofmassspectrometry |