Registered replication report: Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998)
Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998) reported that participants primed with a category associated with intelligence (“professor”) subsequently performed 13% better on a trivia test than participants primed with a category associated with a lack of intelligence (“soccer hooligans”). In two unpubli...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Published: |
SAGE Publications
2018
|
| _version_ | 1797074353092820992 |
|---|---|
| author | O’Donnell, M Nelson, LD Ackermann, E Aczel, B Akhtar, A Aldrovandi, S Alshaif, N Andringa, R Aveyard, M Babincak, P Balatekin, N Baldwin, SA Banik, G Baskin, E Bell, R Białobrzeska, O Birt, AR Boot, WR Braithwaite, SR Briggs, JC Buchner, A Budd, D Budzik, K Bullens, L Bulley, RL Cannon, PR Cantarero, K Cesario, J Chambers, S Chartier, CR Chekroun, P Chong, C Cleeremans, A Coary, SP Coulthard, J Cramwinckel, FM Denson, TF Díaz-Lago, M Didonato, TE Drummond, A Eberlen, J Ebersbach, T Edlund, JE Finnigan, KM Fisher, J Frankowska, N García-Sánchez, E Golom, FD Graves, AJ Greenberg, K Hanioti, M Hansen, HA Harder, JA Harrell, ER Hartanto, A Inzlicht, M Johnson, DJ Karpinski, A Keller, VN Klein, O Koppel, L Krahmer, E Lantian, A Larson, MJ Légal, J-B Lucas, RE Lynott, D Magaldino, CM Massar, K McBee, MT McLatchie, N Melia, N Mensink, MC Mieth, L Moore-Berg, S Neeser, G Newell, BR Noordewier, MK Özdoğru, A Pantazi, M Parzuchowski, M Peters, K Philipp, MC Pollmann, MMH Rentzelas, P Rodríguez-Bailón, R Röer, J Ropovik, I Roque, NA Rueda, C Rutjens, BT Sackett, K Salamon, J Sánchez-Rodríguez, Á Saunders, B Schaafsma, J Schulte-Mecklenbeck, M Shanks, DR Sherman, MF Steele, KM Steffens, NK Sun, J Susa, KJ Szaszi, B Szollosi, A Tamayo, RM Tinghög, G Tong, Y-Y Tweten, C Vadillo, MA Valcarcel, D Van Der Linden, N Van Elk, M Van Harreveld, F Västfjäll, D Vazire, S Verduyn, P Williams, MN Willis, GB Wood, SE Yang, C Zerhouni, O Zheng, R Zrubka, M |
| author_facet | O’Donnell, M Nelson, LD Ackermann, E Aczel, B Akhtar, A Aldrovandi, S Alshaif, N Andringa, R Aveyard, M Babincak, P Balatekin, N Baldwin, SA Banik, G Baskin, E Bell, R Białobrzeska, O Birt, AR Boot, WR Braithwaite, SR Briggs, JC Buchner, A Budd, D Budzik, K Bullens, L Bulley, RL Cannon, PR Cantarero, K Cesario, J Chambers, S Chartier, CR Chekroun, P Chong, C Cleeremans, A Coary, SP Coulthard, J Cramwinckel, FM Denson, TF Díaz-Lago, M Didonato, TE Drummond, A Eberlen, J Ebersbach, T Edlund, JE Finnigan, KM Fisher, J Frankowska, N García-Sánchez, E Golom, FD Graves, AJ Greenberg, K Hanioti, M Hansen, HA Harder, JA Harrell, ER Hartanto, A Inzlicht, M Johnson, DJ Karpinski, A Keller, VN Klein, O Koppel, L Krahmer, E Lantian, A Larson, MJ Légal, J-B Lucas, RE Lynott, D Magaldino, CM Massar, K McBee, MT McLatchie, N Melia, N Mensink, MC Mieth, L Moore-Berg, S Neeser, G Newell, BR Noordewier, MK Özdoğru, A Pantazi, M Parzuchowski, M Peters, K Philipp, MC Pollmann, MMH Rentzelas, P Rodríguez-Bailón, R Röer, J Ropovik, I Roque, NA Rueda, C Rutjens, BT Sackett, K Salamon, J Sánchez-Rodríguez, Á Saunders, B Schaafsma, J Schulte-Mecklenbeck, M Shanks, DR Sherman, MF Steele, KM Steffens, NK Sun, J Susa, KJ Szaszi, B Szollosi, A Tamayo, RM Tinghög, G Tong, Y-Y Tweten, C Vadillo, MA Valcarcel, D Van Der Linden, N Van Elk, M Van Harreveld, F Västfjäll, D Vazire, S Verduyn, P Williams, MN Willis, GB Wood, SE Yang, C Zerhouni, O Zheng, R Zrubka, M |
| author_sort | O’Donnell, M |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998) reported that participants primed with a category associated with intelligence (“professor”) subsequently performed 13% better on a trivia test than participants primed with a category associated with a lack of intelligence (“soccer hooligans”). In two unpublished replications of this study designed to verify the appropriate testing procedures, Dijksterhuis, van Knippenberg, and Holland observed a smaller difference between conditions (2%–3%) as well as a gender difference: Men showed the effect (9.3% and 7.6%), but women did not (0.3% and −0.3%). The procedure used in those replications served as the basis for this multilab Registered Replication Report. A total of 40 laboratories collected data for this project, and 23 of these laboratories met all inclusion criteria. Here we report the meta-analytic results for those 23 direct replications (total N = 4,493), which tested whether performance on a 30-item general-knowledge trivia task differed between these two priming conditions (results of supplementary analyses of the data from all 40 labs, N = 6,454, are also reported). We observed no overall difference in trivia performance between participants primed with the “professor” category and those primed with the “hooligan” category (0.14%) and no moderation by gender. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-06T23:34:58Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:6d53cee5-d505-4a55-b081-ba75e1ca3dbc |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-06T23:34:58Z |
| publishDate | 2018 |
| publisher | SAGE Publications |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:6d53cee5-d505-4a55-b081-ba75e1ca3dbc2022-03-26T19:17:27ZRegistered replication report: Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998)Journal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:6d53cee5-d505-4a55-b081-ba75e1ca3dbcSymplectic Elements at OxfordSAGE Publications2018O’Donnell, MNelson, LDAckermann, EAczel, BAkhtar, AAldrovandi, SAlshaif, NAndringa, RAveyard, MBabincak, PBalatekin, NBaldwin, SABanik, GBaskin, EBell, RBiałobrzeska, OBirt, ARBoot, WRBraithwaite, SRBriggs, JCBuchner, ABudd, DBudzik, KBullens, LBulley, RLCannon, PRCantarero, KCesario, JChambers, SChartier, CRChekroun, PChong, CCleeremans, ACoary, SPCoulthard, JCramwinckel, FMDenson, TFDíaz-Lago, MDidonato, TEDrummond, AEberlen, JEbersbach, TEdlund, JEFinnigan, KMFisher, JFrankowska, NGarcía-Sánchez, EGolom, FDGraves, AJGreenberg, KHanioti, MHansen, HAHarder, JAHarrell, ERHartanto, AInzlicht, MJohnson, DJKarpinski, AKeller, VNKlein, OKoppel, LKrahmer, ELantian, ALarson, MJLégal, J-BLucas, RELynott, DMagaldino, CMMassar, KMcBee, MTMcLatchie, NMelia, NMensink, MCMieth, LMoore-Berg, SNeeser, GNewell, BRNoordewier, MKÖzdoğru, APantazi, MParzuchowski, MPeters, KPhilipp, MCPollmann, MMHRentzelas, PRodríguez-Bailón, RRöer, JRopovik, IRoque, NARueda, CRutjens, BTSackett, KSalamon, JSánchez-Rodríguez, ÁSaunders, BSchaafsma, JSchulte-Mecklenbeck, MShanks, DRSherman, MFSteele, KMSteffens, NKSun, JSusa, KJSzaszi, BSzollosi, ATamayo, RMTinghög, GTong, Y-YTweten, CVadillo, MAValcarcel, DVan Der Linden, NVan Elk, MVan Harreveld, FVästfjäll, DVazire, SVerduyn, PWilliams, MNWillis, GBWood, SEYang, CZerhouni, OZheng, RZrubka, MDijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998) reported that participants primed with a category associated with intelligence (“professor”) subsequently performed 13% better on a trivia test than participants primed with a category associated with a lack of intelligence (“soccer hooligans”). In two unpublished replications of this study designed to verify the appropriate testing procedures, Dijksterhuis, van Knippenberg, and Holland observed a smaller difference between conditions (2%–3%) as well as a gender difference: Men showed the effect (9.3% and 7.6%), but women did not (0.3% and −0.3%). The procedure used in those replications served as the basis for this multilab Registered Replication Report. A total of 40 laboratories collected data for this project, and 23 of these laboratories met all inclusion criteria. Here we report the meta-analytic results for those 23 direct replications (total N = 4,493), which tested whether performance on a 30-item general-knowledge trivia task differed between these two priming conditions (results of supplementary analyses of the data from all 40 labs, N = 6,454, are also reported). We observed no overall difference in trivia performance between participants primed with the “professor” category and those primed with the “hooligan” category (0.14%) and no moderation by gender. |
| spellingShingle | O’Donnell, M Nelson, LD Ackermann, E Aczel, B Akhtar, A Aldrovandi, S Alshaif, N Andringa, R Aveyard, M Babincak, P Balatekin, N Baldwin, SA Banik, G Baskin, E Bell, R Białobrzeska, O Birt, AR Boot, WR Braithwaite, SR Briggs, JC Buchner, A Budd, D Budzik, K Bullens, L Bulley, RL Cannon, PR Cantarero, K Cesario, J Chambers, S Chartier, CR Chekroun, P Chong, C Cleeremans, A Coary, SP Coulthard, J Cramwinckel, FM Denson, TF Díaz-Lago, M Didonato, TE Drummond, A Eberlen, J Ebersbach, T Edlund, JE Finnigan, KM Fisher, J Frankowska, N García-Sánchez, E Golom, FD Graves, AJ Greenberg, K Hanioti, M Hansen, HA Harder, JA Harrell, ER Hartanto, A Inzlicht, M Johnson, DJ Karpinski, A Keller, VN Klein, O Koppel, L Krahmer, E Lantian, A Larson, MJ Légal, J-B Lucas, RE Lynott, D Magaldino, CM Massar, K McBee, MT McLatchie, N Melia, N Mensink, MC Mieth, L Moore-Berg, S Neeser, G Newell, BR Noordewier, MK Özdoğru, A Pantazi, M Parzuchowski, M Peters, K Philipp, MC Pollmann, MMH Rentzelas, P Rodríguez-Bailón, R Röer, J Ropovik, I Roque, NA Rueda, C Rutjens, BT Sackett, K Salamon, J Sánchez-Rodríguez, Á Saunders, B Schaafsma, J Schulte-Mecklenbeck, M Shanks, DR Sherman, MF Steele, KM Steffens, NK Sun, J Susa, KJ Szaszi, B Szollosi, A Tamayo, RM Tinghög, G Tong, Y-Y Tweten, C Vadillo, MA Valcarcel, D Van Der Linden, N Van Elk, M Van Harreveld, F Västfjäll, D Vazire, S Verduyn, P Williams, MN Willis, GB Wood, SE Yang, C Zerhouni, O Zheng, R Zrubka, M Registered replication report: Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998) |
| title | Registered replication report: Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998) |
| title_full | Registered replication report: Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998) |
| title_fullStr | Registered replication report: Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998) |
| title_full_unstemmed | Registered replication report: Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998) |
| title_short | Registered replication report: Dijksterhuis and van Knippenberg (1998) |
| title_sort | registered replication report dijksterhuis and van knippenberg 1998 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT odonnellm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT nelsonld registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT ackermanne registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT aczelb registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT akhtara registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT aldrovandis registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT alshaifn registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT andringar registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT aveyardm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT babincakp registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT balatekinn registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT baldwinsa registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT banikg registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT baskine registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT bellr registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT białobrzeskao registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT birtar registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT bootwr registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT braithwaitesr registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT briggsjc registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT buchnera registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT buddd registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT budzikk registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT bullensl registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT bulleyrl registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT cannonpr registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT cantarerok registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT cesarioj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT chamberss registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT chartiercr registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT chekrounp registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT chongc registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT cleeremansa registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT coarysp registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT coulthardj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT cramwinckelfm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT densontf registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT diazlagom registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT didonatote registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT drummonda registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT eberlenj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT ebersbacht registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT edlundje registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT finnigankm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT fisherj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT frankowskan registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT garciasancheze registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT golomfd registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT gravesaj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT greenbergk registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT haniotim registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT hansenha registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT harderja registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT harreller registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT hartantoa registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT inzlichtm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT johnsondj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT karpinskia registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT kellervn registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT kleino registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT koppell registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT krahmere registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT lantiana registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT larsonmj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT legaljb registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT lucasre registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT lynottd registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT magaldinocm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT massark registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT mcbeemt registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT mclatchien registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT melian registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT mensinkmc registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT miethl registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT moorebergs registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT neeserg registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT newellbr registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT noordewiermk registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT ozdogrua registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT pantazim registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT parzuchowskim registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT petersk registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT philippmc registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT pollmannmmh registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT rentzelasp registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT rodriguezbailonr registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT roerj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT ropoviki registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT roquena registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT ruedac registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT rutjensbt registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT sackettk registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT salamonj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT sanchezrodrigueza registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT saundersb registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT schaafsmaj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT schultemecklenbeckm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT shanksdr registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT shermanmf registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT steelekm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT steffensnk registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT sunj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT susakj registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT szaszib registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT szollosia registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT tamayorm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT tinghogg registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT tongyy registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT twetenc registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT vadilloma registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT valcarceld registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT vanderlindenn registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT vanelkm registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT vanharreveldf registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT vastfjalld registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT vazires registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT verduynp registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT williamsmn registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT willisgb registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT woodse registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT yangc registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT zerhounio registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT zhengr registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 AT zrubkam registeredreplicationreportdijksterhuisandvanknippenberg1998 |