What can be learnt about disease progression in breast cancer dormancy from relapse data?
Breast cancer patients have an anomalously high rate of relapse many years–up to 25 years–after apparently curative surgery removed the primary tumour. Disease progression during the intervening years between resection and relapse is poorly understood. There is evidence that the disease persists as...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Public Library of Science
2013
|
| _version_ | 1826281129640984576 |
|---|---|
| author | Willis, L Graham, T Alarcón, T Alison, MR Tomlinson, I Page, K |
| author_facet | Willis, L Graham, T Alarcón, T Alison, MR Tomlinson, I Page, K |
| author_sort | Willis, L |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | Breast cancer patients have an anomalously high rate of relapse many years–up to 25 years–after apparently curative surgery removed the primary tumour. Disease progression during the intervening years between resection and relapse is poorly understood. There is evidence that the disease persists as dangerous, tiny metastases that remain at a growth restricted, clinically undetectable size until a transforming event restarts growth. This is the starting point for our study, where patients who have metastases that are all tiny and growth-restricted are said to have cancer dormancy. Can long-term follow-up relapse data from breast cancer patients be used to extract knowledge about the progression of the undetected disease? Here, we evaluate whether this is the case by introducing and analysing four simple mathematical models of cancer dormancy. These models extend the common assumption that a random transforming event, such as a mutation, can restart growth of a tiny, growth-restricted metastasis; thereafter, cancer dormancy progresses to detectable metastasis. We find that physiopathological details, such as the number of random transforming events that metastases must undergo to escape from growth restriction, cannot be extracted from relapse data. This result is unsurprising. However, the same analysis suggested a natural question that does have a surprising answer: why are interesting trends in long-term relapse data not more commonly observed? Further, our models indicate that (a) therapies which induce growth restriction among metastases but do not prevent increases in metastases' tumourigenicity may introduce a time post-surgery when more patients are prone to relapse; and (b), if a number of facts about disease progression are first established, how relapse data might be used to estimate clinically relevant variables, such as the likely numbers of undetected growth-restricted metastases. This work is a necessary, early step in building a quantitative mechanistic understanding of cancer dormancy. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T00:24:09Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:7d8bc2bc-b3c8-4adf-a230-eb1c0f778873 |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T00:24:09Z |
| publishDate | 2013 |
| publisher | Public Library of Science |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:7d8bc2bc-b3c8-4adf-a230-eb1c0f7788732022-03-26T21:04:26ZWhat can be learnt about disease progression in breast cancer dormancy from relapse data?Journal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:7d8bc2bc-b3c8-4adf-a230-eb1c0f778873EnglishSymplectic Elements at OxfordPublic Library of Science2013Willis, LGraham, TAlarcón, TAlison, MRTomlinson, IPage, KBreast cancer patients have an anomalously high rate of relapse many years–up to 25 years–after apparently curative surgery removed the primary tumour. Disease progression during the intervening years between resection and relapse is poorly understood. There is evidence that the disease persists as dangerous, tiny metastases that remain at a growth restricted, clinically undetectable size until a transforming event restarts growth. This is the starting point for our study, where patients who have metastases that are all tiny and growth-restricted are said to have cancer dormancy. Can long-term follow-up relapse data from breast cancer patients be used to extract knowledge about the progression of the undetected disease? Here, we evaluate whether this is the case by introducing and analysing four simple mathematical models of cancer dormancy. These models extend the common assumption that a random transforming event, such as a mutation, can restart growth of a tiny, growth-restricted metastasis; thereafter, cancer dormancy progresses to detectable metastasis. We find that physiopathological details, such as the number of random transforming events that metastases must undergo to escape from growth restriction, cannot be extracted from relapse data. This result is unsurprising. However, the same analysis suggested a natural question that does have a surprising answer: why are interesting trends in long-term relapse data not more commonly observed? Further, our models indicate that (a) therapies which induce growth restriction among metastases but do not prevent increases in metastases' tumourigenicity may introduce a time post-surgery when more patients are prone to relapse; and (b), if a number of facts about disease progression are first established, how relapse data might be used to estimate clinically relevant variables, such as the likely numbers of undetected growth-restricted metastases. This work is a necessary, early step in building a quantitative mechanistic understanding of cancer dormancy. |
| spellingShingle | Willis, L Graham, T Alarcón, T Alison, MR Tomlinson, I Page, K What can be learnt about disease progression in breast cancer dormancy from relapse data? |
| title | What can be learnt about disease progression in breast cancer dormancy from relapse data? |
| title_full | What can be learnt about disease progression in breast cancer dormancy from relapse data? |
| title_fullStr | What can be learnt about disease progression in breast cancer dormancy from relapse data? |
| title_full_unstemmed | What can be learnt about disease progression in breast cancer dormancy from relapse data? |
| title_short | What can be learnt about disease progression in breast cancer dormancy from relapse data? |
| title_sort | what can be learnt about disease progression in breast cancer dormancy from relapse data |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT willisl whatcanbelearntaboutdiseaseprogressioninbreastcancerdormancyfromrelapsedata AT grahamt whatcanbelearntaboutdiseaseprogressioninbreastcancerdormancyfromrelapsedata AT alarcont whatcanbelearntaboutdiseaseprogressioninbreastcancerdormancyfromrelapsedata AT alisonmr whatcanbelearntaboutdiseaseprogressioninbreastcancerdormancyfromrelapsedata AT tomlinsoni whatcanbelearntaboutdiseaseprogressioninbreastcancerdormancyfromrelapsedata AT pagek whatcanbelearntaboutdiseaseprogressioninbreastcancerdormancyfromrelapsedata |