Performance of antigen lateral flow devices in the UK during the alpha, delta, and omicron waves of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic: a diagnostic and observational study
<p><strong>Background:</strong> Antigen lateral flow devices (LFDs) have been widely used to control SARS-CoV-2. We aimed to improve understanding of LFD performance with changes in variant infections, vaccination, viral load, and LFD use, and in the detection of infectiou...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Elsevier
2023
|
| _version_ | 1797111605851324416 |
|---|---|
| author | Eyre, DW Futschik, M Tunkel, S Wei, J Cole-Hamilton, J Saquib, R Germanacos, N Dodgson, AR Klapper, PE Sudhanva, M Kenny, C Marks, P Blandford, E Hopkins, S Peto, TEA Fowler, T |
| author_facet | Eyre, DW Futschik, M Tunkel, S Wei, J Cole-Hamilton, J Saquib, R Germanacos, N Dodgson, AR Klapper, PE Sudhanva, M Kenny, C Marks, P Blandford, E Hopkins, S Peto, TEA Fowler, T |
| author_sort | Eyre, DW |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | <p><strong>Background:</strong> Antigen lateral flow devices (LFDs) have been widely used to control SARS-CoV-2. We aimed to improve understanding of LFD performance with changes in variant infections, vaccination, viral load, and LFD use, and in the detection of infectious individuals.</p>
<p><strong>Methods:</strong> In this diagnostic study, paired LFD and RT-PCR test results were prospectively collected from asymptomatic and symptomatic participants in the UK between Nov 4, 2020, and March 21, 2022, to support the National Health Service (NHS) England's Test and Trace programme. The LFDs evaluated were the Innova SARS-CoV-2 Antigen Rapid Qualitative Test, the Orient Gene Rapid Covid-19 (Antigen) Self-Test, and the Acon Flowflex SARS-CoV-2 Antigen Rapid Test (Self-Testing). Test results were collected across various community testing settings, including predeployment testing sites, routine testing centres, homes, schools, universities, workplaces, targeted community testing, and from health-care workers. We used multivariable logistic regression to analyse LFD sensitivity and specificity using RT-PCR as a reference standard, adjusting for viral load, LFD manufacturer, test setting, age, sex, test assistance, symptom status, vaccination status, and SARS-CoV-2 variant. National contact tracing data from NHS Test and Trace (Jan 1, 2021, to Jan 11, 2022) were used to estimate the proportion of transmitting index patients (with ≥1 RT-PCR-positive or LFD-positive contact) potentially detectable by LFDs (specifically Innova, as the most widely used LFD) with time, accounting for index viral load, variant, and symptom status.</p>
<p><strong>Findings:</strong> We assessed 75 382 pairs of LFD and RT-PCR tests. Of these, 4131 (5·5%) were RT-PCR-positive. LFD sensitivity versus RT-PCR was 63·2% (95% CI 61·7–64·6) and specificity was 99·71% (95% CI 99·66–99·74). Increased viral load was independently associated with being LFD positive (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 2·85 [95% CI 2·66–3·06] per 1 log<sub>10</sub> copies per mL increase; p<0·0001). There was no evidence that LFD sensitivity differed for delta (B.1.617.2) infections <em>versus</em> alpha (B.1.1.7) or pre-alpha (B.1.177) infections (aOR 1·00 [0·69–1·45]; p=0·99), whereas omicron (BA.1 or BA.2) infections appeared more likely to be LFD positive (aOR 1·63 [1·02–2·59]; p=0·042). Sensitivity was higher in symptomatic participants (68·7% [95% CI 66·9–70·4]) than in asymptomatic participants (52·8% [50·1–55·4]). Among 347 374 unique index patients with probable onward transmission, 78·3% (95% CI 75·3–81·2) were estimated to have been detectable with LFDs (Innova), and this proportion was mostly stable with time and for successive variants. Overall, the estimated proportion of infectious index patients detectable by the Innova LFD was lower in asymptomatic patients (57·6% [53·6–61·9]) versus symptomatic patients (79·7% [76·7–82·5]).</p>
<p><strong>Interpretation:</strong> LFDs remained able to detect most SARS-CoV-2 infections throughout vaccine roll-out and across different viral variants. LFDs can potentially detect most infections that transmit to others and reduce the risk of transmission. However, performance is lower in asymptomatic individuals than in symptomatic individuals.</p> |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T08:12:46Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:83bace3f-d6f0-4f46-9f53-67dbadad9f99 |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T08:12:46Z |
| publishDate | 2023 |
| publisher | Elsevier |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:83bace3f-d6f0-4f46-9f53-67dbadad9f992023-12-06T12:11:25ZPerformance of antigen lateral flow devices in the UK during the alpha, delta, and omicron waves of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic: a diagnostic and observational studyJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:83bace3f-d6f0-4f46-9f53-67dbadad9f99EnglishSymplectic ElementsElsevier2023Eyre, DWFutschik, MTunkel, SWei, JCole-Hamilton, JSaquib, RGermanacos, NDodgson, ARKlapper, PESudhanva, MKenny, CMarks, PBlandford, EHopkins, SPeto, TEAFowler, T<p><strong>Background:</strong> Antigen lateral flow devices (LFDs) have been widely used to control SARS-CoV-2. We aimed to improve understanding of LFD performance with changes in variant infections, vaccination, viral load, and LFD use, and in the detection of infectious individuals.</p> <p><strong>Methods:</strong> In this diagnostic study, paired LFD and RT-PCR test results were prospectively collected from asymptomatic and symptomatic participants in the UK between Nov 4, 2020, and March 21, 2022, to support the National Health Service (NHS) England's Test and Trace programme. The LFDs evaluated were the Innova SARS-CoV-2 Antigen Rapid Qualitative Test, the Orient Gene Rapid Covid-19 (Antigen) Self-Test, and the Acon Flowflex SARS-CoV-2 Antigen Rapid Test (Self-Testing). Test results were collected across various community testing settings, including predeployment testing sites, routine testing centres, homes, schools, universities, workplaces, targeted community testing, and from health-care workers. We used multivariable logistic regression to analyse LFD sensitivity and specificity using RT-PCR as a reference standard, adjusting for viral load, LFD manufacturer, test setting, age, sex, test assistance, symptom status, vaccination status, and SARS-CoV-2 variant. National contact tracing data from NHS Test and Trace (Jan 1, 2021, to Jan 11, 2022) were used to estimate the proportion of transmitting index patients (with ≥1 RT-PCR-positive or LFD-positive contact) potentially detectable by LFDs (specifically Innova, as the most widely used LFD) with time, accounting for index viral load, variant, and symptom status.</p> <p><strong>Findings:</strong> We assessed 75 382 pairs of LFD and RT-PCR tests. Of these, 4131 (5·5%) were RT-PCR-positive. LFD sensitivity versus RT-PCR was 63·2% (95% CI 61·7–64·6) and specificity was 99·71% (95% CI 99·66–99·74). Increased viral load was independently associated with being LFD positive (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 2·85 [95% CI 2·66–3·06] per 1 log<sub>10</sub> copies per mL increase; p<0·0001). There was no evidence that LFD sensitivity differed for delta (B.1.617.2) infections <em>versus</em> alpha (B.1.1.7) or pre-alpha (B.1.177) infections (aOR 1·00 [0·69–1·45]; p=0·99), whereas omicron (BA.1 or BA.2) infections appeared more likely to be LFD positive (aOR 1·63 [1·02–2·59]; p=0·042). Sensitivity was higher in symptomatic participants (68·7% [95% CI 66·9–70·4]) than in asymptomatic participants (52·8% [50·1–55·4]). Among 347 374 unique index patients with probable onward transmission, 78·3% (95% CI 75·3–81·2) were estimated to have been detectable with LFDs (Innova), and this proportion was mostly stable with time and for successive variants. Overall, the estimated proportion of infectious index patients detectable by the Innova LFD was lower in asymptomatic patients (57·6% [53·6–61·9]) versus symptomatic patients (79·7% [76·7–82·5]).</p> <p><strong>Interpretation:</strong> LFDs remained able to detect most SARS-CoV-2 infections throughout vaccine roll-out and across different viral variants. LFDs can potentially detect most infections that transmit to others and reduce the risk of transmission. However, performance is lower in asymptomatic individuals than in symptomatic individuals.</p> |
| spellingShingle | Eyre, DW Futschik, M Tunkel, S Wei, J Cole-Hamilton, J Saquib, R Germanacos, N Dodgson, AR Klapper, PE Sudhanva, M Kenny, C Marks, P Blandford, E Hopkins, S Peto, TEA Fowler, T Performance of antigen lateral flow devices in the UK during the alpha, delta, and omicron waves of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic: a diagnostic and observational study |
| title | Performance of antigen lateral flow devices in the UK during the alpha, delta, and omicron waves of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic: a diagnostic and observational study |
| title_full | Performance of antigen lateral flow devices in the UK during the alpha, delta, and omicron waves of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic: a diagnostic and observational study |
| title_fullStr | Performance of antigen lateral flow devices in the UK during the alpha, delta, and omicron waves of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic: a diagnostic and observational study |
| title_full_unstemmed | Performance of antigen lateral flow devices in the UK during the alpha, delta, and omicron waves of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic: a diagnostic and observational study |
| title_short | Performance of antigen lateral flow devices in the UK during the alpha, delta, and omicron waves of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic: a diagnostic and observational study |
| title_sort | performance of antigen lateral flow devices in the uk during the alpha delta and omicron waves of the sars cov 2 pandemic a diagnostic and observational study |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT eyredw performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT futschikm performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT tunkels performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT weij performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT colehamiltonj performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT saquibr performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT germanacosn performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT dodgsonar performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT klapperpe performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT sudhanvam performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT kennyc performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT marksp performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT blandforde performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT hopkinss performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT petotea performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy AT fowlert performanceofantigenlateralflowdevicesintheukduringthealphadeltaandomicronwavesofthesarscov2pandemicadiagnosticandobservationalstudy |