Subcortical brain structure and suicidal behaviour in major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-MDD working group
The aetiology of suicidal behaviour is complex, and knowledge about its neurobiological mechanisms is limited. Neuroimaging methods provide a noninvasive approach to explore the neural correlates of suicide vulnerability in vivo. The ENIGMA-MDD Working Group is an international collaboration evaluat...
| Hoofdauteurs: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Formaat: | Journal article |
| Taal: | English |
| Gepubliceerd in: |
Nature Publishing Group
2017
|
| _version_ | 1826282641856397312 |
|---|---|
| author | Rentería, ME Schmaal, L Hibar, DP Couvy-Duchesne, B Strike, LT Mills, NT de Zubicaray, GI McMahon, KL Medland, SE Gillespie, NA Hatton, SN Lagopoulos, J Veltman, DJ van der Wee, N van Erp, TGM Wittfeld, K Grabe, HJ Block, A Hegenscheid, K Völzke, H Veer, IM Walter, H Schnell, K Schramm, E Normann, C Schoepf, D Konrad, C Zurowski, B Godlewska, BR Cowen, PJ Penninx, BWJH Jahanshad, N Thompson, PM Wright, MJ Martin, NG Christensen, H Hickie, IB |
| author_facet | Rentería, ME Schmaal, L Hibar, DP Couvy-Duchesne, B Strike, LT Mills, NT de Zubicaray, GI McMahon, KL Medland, SE Gillespie, NA Hatton, SN Lagopoulos, J Veltman, DJ van der Wee, N van Erp, TGM Wittfeld, K Grabe, HJ Block, A Hegenscheid, K Völzke, H Veer, IM Walter, H Schnell, K Schramm, E Normann, C Schoepf, D Konrad, C Zurowski, B Godlewska, BR Cowen, PJ Penninx, BWJH Jahanshad, N Thompson, PM Wright, MJ Martin, NG Christensen, H Hickie, IB |
| author_sort | Rentería, ME |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | The aetiology of suicidal behaviour is complex, and knowledge about its neurobiological mechanisms is limited. Neuroimaging methods provide a noninvasive approach to explore the neural correlates of suicide vulnerability in vivo. The ENIGMA-MDD Working Group is an international collaboration evaluating neuroimaging and clinical data from thousands of individuals collected by research groups from around the world. Here we present analyses in a subset sample (n=3097) for whom suicidality data were available. Prevalence of suicidal symptoms among major depressive disorder (MDD) cases ranged between 29 and 69% across cohorts. We compared mean subcortical grey matter volumes, lateral ventricle volumes and total intracranial volume (ICV) in MDD patients with suicidal symptoms (N=451) vs healthy controls (N=1996) or MDD patients with no suicidal symptoms (N=650). MDD patients reporting suicidal plans or attempts showed a smaller ICV (P=4.12 × 10-3) or a 2.87% smaller volume compared with controls (Cohen's d=-0.284). In addition, we observed a nonsignificant trend in which MDD cases with suicidal symptoms had smaller subcortical volumes and larger ventricular volumes compared with controls. Finally, no significant differences (P=0.28-0.97) were found between MDD patients with and those without suicidal symptoms for any of the brain volume measures. This is by far the largest neuroimaging meta-analysis of suicidal behaviour in MDD to date. Our results did not replicate previous reports of association between subcortical brain structure and suicidality and highlight the need for collecting better-powered imaging samples and using improved suicidality assessment instruments. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T00:46:55Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:8500096f-99c5-45bc-9102-5470c8d8e700 |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T00:46:55Z |
| publishDate | 2017 |
| publisher | Nature Publishing Group |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:8500096f-99c5-45bc-9102-5470c8d8e7002022-03-26T21:54:37ZSubcortical brain structure and suicidal behaviour in major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-MDD working groupJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:8500096f-99c5-45bc-9102-5470c8d8e700EnglishSymplectic Elements at OxfordNature Publishing Group2017Rentería, MESchmaal, LHibar, DPCouvy-Duchesne, BStrike, LTMills, NTde Zubicaray, GIMcMahon, KLMedland, SEGillespie, NAHatton, SNLagopoulos, JVeltman, DJvan der Wee, Nvan Erp, TGMWittfeld, KGrabe, HJBlock, AHegenscheid, KVölzke, HVeer, IMWalter, HSchnell, KSchramm, ENormann, CSchoepf, DKonrad, CZurowski, BGodlewska, BRCowen, PJPenninx, BWJHJahanshad, NThompson, PMWright, MJMartin, NGChristensen, HHickie, IBThe aetiology of suicidal behaviour is complex, and knowledge about its neurobiological mechanisms is limited. Neuroimaging methods provide a noninvasive approach to explore the neural correlates of suicide vulnerability in vivo. The ENIGMA-MDD Working Group is an international collaboration evaluating neuroimaging and clinical data from thousands of individuals collected by research groups from around the world. Here we present analyses in a subset sample (n=3097) for whom suicidality data were available. Prevalence of suicidal symptoms among major depressive disorder (MDD) cases ranged between 29 and 69% across cohorts. We compared mean subcortical grey matter volumes, lateral ventricle volumes and total intracranial volume (ICV) in MDD patients with suicidal symptoms (N=451) vs healthy controls (N=1996) or MDD patients with no suicidal symptoms (N=650). MDD patients reporting suicidal plans or attempts showed a smaller ICV (P=4.12 × 10-3) or a 2.87% smaller volume compared with controls (Cohen's d=-0.284). In addition, we observed a nonsignificant trend in which MDD cases with suicidal symptoms had smaller subcortical volumes and larger ventricular volumes compared with controls. Finally, no significant differences (P=0.28-0.97) were found between MDD patients with and those without suicidal symptoms for any of the brain volume measures. This is by far the largest neuroimaging meta-analysis of suicidal behaviour in MDD to date. Our results did not replicate previous reports of association between subcortical brain structure and suicidality and highlight the need for collecting better-powered imaging samples and using improved suicidality assessment instruments. |
| spellingShingle | Rentería, ME Schmaal, L Hibar, DP Couvy-Duchesne, B Strike, LT Mills, NT de Zubicaray, GI McMahon, KL Medland, SE Gillespie, NA Hatton, SN Lagopoulos, J Veltman, DJ van der Wee, N van Erp, TGM Wittfeld, K Grabe, HJ Block, A Hegenscheid, K Völzke, H Veer, IM Walter, H Schnell, K Schramm, E Normann, C Schoepf, D Konrad, C Zurowski, B Godlewska, BR Cowen, PJ Penninx, BWJH Jahanshad, N Thompson, PM Wright, MJ Martin, NG Christensen, H Hickie, IB Subcortical brain structure and suicidal behaviour in major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-MDD working group |
| title | Subcortical brain structure and suicidal behaviour in major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-MDD working group |
| title_full | Subcortical brain structure and suicidal behaviour in major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-MDD working group |
| title_fullStr | Subcortical brain structure and suicidal behaviour in major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-MDD working group |
| title_full_unstemmed | Subcortical brain structure and suicidal behaviour in major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-MDD working group |
| title_short | Subcortical brain structure and suicidal behaviour in major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis from the ENIGMA-MDD working group |
| title_sort | subcortical brain structure and suicidal behaviour in major depressive disorder a meta analysis from the enigma mdd working group |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT renteriame subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT schmaall subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT hibardp subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT couvyduchesneb subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT strikelt subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT millsnt subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT dezubicaraygi subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT mcmahonkl subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT medlandse subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT gillespiena subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT hattonsn subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT lagopoulosj subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT veltmandj subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT vanderween subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT vanerptgm subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT wittfeldk subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT grabehj subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT blocka subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT hegenscheidk subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT volzkeh subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT veerim subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT walterh subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT schnellk subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT schramme subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT normannc subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT schoepfd subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT konradc subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT zurowskib subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT godlewskabr subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT cowenpj subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT penninxbwjh subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT jahanshadn subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT thompsonpm subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT wrightmj subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT martinng subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT christensenh subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup AT hickieib subcorticalbrainstructureandsuicidalbehaviourinmajordepressivedisorderametaanalysisfromtheenigmamddworkinggroup |