Garnet stability during crustal melting: implications for chemical mohometry and secular change in arc magmatism and continent formation
Understanding how new felsic crust is formed and subsequently evolves through time is critical to identifying the geodynamic regimes that have dominated various parts of Earth history, and have important implications for feedbacks between the lithosphere and biosphere, such as controlling the influx...
| Main Authors: | , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Elsevier
2024
|
| _version_ | 1826314928374415360 |
|---|---|
| author | Roberts, NMW Hernández-Montenegro, JD Palin, RM |
| author_facet | Roberts, NMW Hernández-Montenegro, JD Palin, RM |
| author_sort | Roberts, NMW |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | Understanding how new felsic crust is formed and subsequently evolves through time is critical to identifying the geodynamic regimes that have dominated various parts of Earth history, and have important implications for feedbacks between the lithosphere and biosphere, such as controlling the influx of continental detritus into the oceans. In recent years, several trace element-based geochemical proxies have been proposed to allow determination of paleo-crustal thicknesses, which have been calibrated primarily using data collected from modern-day arcs. The application of these proxies through deep time has revealed surprising results, including the suggestion that the mid-Proterozoic continents were atypically thin compared to those in the Archean and the Phanerozoic; however, a range of factors may influence commonly cited trace element ratios (e.g. Sr/Y) rather than just crustal depth, leading to additional and unexpected magnitudes of uncertainty. Here we perform geochemical modelling to deduce the effect of variable bulk-rock composition and geothermal gradient on the trace element signature of felsic melts generated in arc systems. Using a range of protoliths representative of deep arc crust, the results show that considerable care must be taken when analysing simple trace element ratios of granitoid melts and making direct interpretations of the pressure of crystallisation. In particular, changes in geothermal gradients and differences in arc basalt composition impart strong controls on the relative stability of garnet and plagioclase during metamorphism and partial melting, and wide ranges of Sr/Y and La/Yb may be produced in derivative felsic melts produced at the same crustal depth. The interpretation of mid-Proterozoic continental arcs being atypically thin may instead be an artefact of underestimation of the active geothermal gradient at the time of magma formation, which acts to reduce Sr/Y and La/Yb ratios, even in normal thickness (∼35–40 km) crust. Furthermore, we argue that the potentially garnet-free residua during the formation of mid-Proterozoic felsic magmas points to crust formation without lower crustal foundering, and thus, that this commonly invoked paradigm for formation of the continental crust may only be applicable to certain periods of Earth history. |
| first_indexed | 2024-12-09T03:16:56Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:856e4e2b-5aa5-4945-bbab-c45610d42d94 |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-12-09T03:16:56Z |
| publishDate | 2024 |
| publisher | Elsevier |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:856e4e2b-5aa5-4945-bbab-c45610d42d942024-10-21T13:19:41ZGarnet stability during crustal melting: implications for chemical mohometry and secular change in arc magmatism and continent formationJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:856e4e2b-5aa5-4945-bbab-c45610d42d94EnglishSymplectic ElementsElsevier2024Roberts, NMWHernández-Montenegro, JDPalin, RMUnderstanding how new felsic crust is formed and subsequently evolves through time is critical to identifying the geodynamic regimes that have dominated various parts of Earth history, and have important implications for feedbacks between the lithosphere and biosphere, such as controlling the influx of continental detritus into the oceans. In recent years, several trace element-based geochemical proxies have been proposed to allow determination of paleo-crustal thicknesses, which have been calibrated primarily using data collected from modern-day arcs. The application of these proxies through deep time has revealed surprising results, including the suggestion that the mid-Proterozoic continents were atypically thin compared to those in the Archean and the Phanerozoic; however, a range of factors may influence commonly cited trace element ratios (e.g. Sr/Y) rather than just crustal depth, leading to additional and unexpected magnitudes of uncertainty. Here we perform geochemical modelling to deduce the effect of variable bulk-rock composition and geothermal gradient on the trace element signature of felsic melts generated in arc systems. Using a range of protoliths representative of deep arc crust, the results show that considerable care must be taken when analysing simple trace element ratios of granitoid melts and making direct interpretations of the pressure of crystallisation. In particular, changes in geothermal gradients and differences in arc basalt composition impart strong controls on the relative stability of garnet and plagioclase during metamorphism and partial melting, and wide ranges of Sr/Y and La/Yb may be produced in derivative felsic melts produced at the same crustal depth. The interpretation of mid-Proterozoic continental arcs being atypically thin may instead be an artefact of underestimation of the active geothermal gradient at the time of magma formation, which acts to reduce Sr/Y and La/Yb ratios, even in normal thickness (∼35–40 km) crust. Furthermore, we argue that the potentially garnet-free residua during the formation of mid-Proterozoic felsic magmas points to crust formation without lower crustal foundering, and thus, that this commonly invoked paradigm for formation of the continental crust may only be applicable to certain periods of Earth history. |
| spellingShingle | Roberts, NMW Hernández-Montenegro, JD Palin, RM Garnet stability during crustal melting: implications for chemical mohometry and secular change in arc magmatism and continent formation |
| title | Garnet stability during crustal melting: implications for chemical mohometry and secular change in arc magmatism and continent formation |
| title_full | Garnet stability during crustal melting: implications for chemical mohometry and secular change in arc magmatism and continent formation |
| title_fullStr | Garnet stability during crustal melting: implications for chemical mohometry and secular change in arc magmatism and continent formation |
| title_full_unstemmed | Garnet stability during crustal melting: implications for chemical mohometry and secular change in arc magmatism and continent formation |
| title_short | Garnet stability during crustal melting: implications for chemical mohometry and secular change in arc magmatism and continent formation |
| title_sort | garnet stability during crustal melting implications for chemical mohometry and secular change in arc magmatism and continent formation |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT robertsnmw garnetstabilityduringcrustalmeltingimplicationsforchemicalmohometryandsecularchangeinarcmagmatismandcontinentformation AT hernandezmontenegrojd garnetstabilityduringcrustalmeltingimplicationsforchemicalmohometryandsecularchangeinarcmagmatismandcontinentformation AT palinrm garnetstabilityduringcrustalmeltingimplicationsforchemicalmohometryandsecularchangeinarcmagmatismandcontinentformation |