The potestas of practice

Can the existence of a social practice justify practical authority? A medi-eval debate between hierocrats and caesaropapists may help to illuminate this ques-tion. Focusing mainly on Marsilius of Padua, with reference to John of Paris, this article suggests that caesaropapists can be read as develop...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Lechterman, TM
Format: Journal article
Language:English
Published: Imprint Academic 2021
Description
Summary:Can the existence of a social practice justify practical authority? A medi-eval debate between hierocrats and caesaropapists may help to illuminate this ques-tion. Focusing mainly on Marsilius of Padua, with reference to John of Paris, this article suggests that caesaropapists can be read as developing a 'practice conception' of the structure and scope of ecclesiastical authority. Because it brings the conflict over authority to a new battleground, the practice conception supplies caesaropapists with a source of dialectical leverage over hierocratic doctrine. The paper explores the strengths and limitations of this methodological approach and links it to debates in contemporary political thought.