Detection of extracolonic pathologic findings with CT colonography: a discrete choice experiment of perceived benefits versus harms.
PURPOSE: To determine the maximum rate of false-positive diagnoses that patients and health care professionals were willing to accept in exchange for detection of extracolonic malignancy by using computed tomographic (CT) colonography for colorectal cancer screening. MATERIALS AND METHODS: After obt...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
2014
|
| _version_ | 1797081583769878528 |
|---|---|
| author | Plumb, A Boone, D Fitzke, H Helbren, E Mallett, S Zhu, S Yao, G Bell, N Ghanouni, A von Wagner, C Taylor, SA Altman, D Lilford, R Halligan, S |
| author_facet | Plumb, A Boone, D Fitzke, H Helbren, E Mallett, S Zhu, S Yao, G Bell, N Ghanouni, A von Wagner, C Taylor, SA Altman, D Lilford, R Halligan, S |
| author_sort | Plumb, A |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | PURPOSE: To determine the maximum rate of false-positive diagnoses that patients and health care professionals were willing to accept in exchange for detection of extracolonic malignancy by using computed tomographic (CT) colonography for colorectal cancer screening. MATERIALS AND METHODS: After obtaining ethical approval and informed consent, 52 patients and 50 health care professionals undertook two discrete choice experiments where they chose between unrestricted CT colonography that examined intra- and extracolonic organs or CT colonography restricted to the colon, across different scenarios. The first experiment detected one extracolonic malignancy per 600 cases with a false-positive rate varying across scenarios from 0% to 99.8%. One experiment examined radiologic follow-up generated by false-positive diagnoses while the other examined invasive follow-up. Intracolonic performance was identical for both tests. The median tipping point (maximum acceptable false-positive rate for extracolonic findings) was calculated overall and for both groups by bootstrap analysis. RESULTS: The median tipping point for radiologic follow-up occurred at a false-positive rate greater than 99.8% (interquartile ratio [IQR], 10 to >99.8%). Participants would tolerate at least a 99.8% rate of unnecessary radiologic tests to detect an additional extracolonic malignancy. The median tipping-point for invasive follow-up occurred at a false-positive rate of 10% (IQR, 2 to >99.8%). Tipping points were significantly higher for patients than for health care professionals for both experiments (>99.8 vs 40% for radiologic follow-up and >99.8 vs 5% for invasive follow-up, both P < .001). CONCLUSION: Patients and health care professionals are willing to tolerate high rates of false-positive diagnoses with CT colonography in exchange for diagnosis of extracolonic malignancy. The actual specificity of screening CT colonography for extracolonic findings in clinical practice is likely to be highly acceptable to both patients and health care professionals. Online supplemental material is available for this article. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T01:16:15Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:8ecd0ba6-87c7-4cfd-a259-aedb2ba88eff |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T01:16:15Z |
| publishDate | 2014 |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:8ecd0ba6-87c7-4cfd-a259-aedb2ba88eff2022-03-26T22:59:59ZDetection of extracolonic pathologic findings with CT colonography: a discrete choice experiment of perceived benefits versus harms.Journal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:8ecd0ba6-87c7-4cfd-a259-aedb2ba88effEnglishSymplectic Elements at Oxford2014Plumb, ABoone, DFitzke, HHelbren, EMallett, SZhu, SYao, GBell, NGhanouni, Avon Wagner, CTaylor, SAAltman, DLilford, RHalligan, SPURPOSE: To determine the maximum rate of false-positive diagnoses that patients and health care professionals were willing to accept in exchange for detection of extracolonic malignancy by using computed tomographic (CT) colonography for colorectal cancer screening. MATERIALS AND METHODS: After obtaining ethical approval and informed consent, 52 patients and 50 health care professionals undertook two discrete choice experiments where they chose between unrestricted CT colonography that examined intra- and extracolonic organs or CT colonography restricted to the colon, across different scenarios. The first experiment detected one extracolonic malignancy per 600 cases with a false-positive rate varying across scenarios from 0% to 99.8%. One experiment examined radiologic follow-up generated by false-positive diagnoses while the other examined invasive follow-up. Intracolonic performance was identical for both tests. The median tipping point (maximum acceptable false-positive rate for extracolonic findings) was calculated overall and for both groups by bootstrap analysis. RESULTS: The median tipping point for radiologic follow-up occurred at a false-positive rate greater than 99.8% (interquartile ratio [IQR], 10 to >99.8%). Participants would tolerate at least a 99.8% rate of unnecessary radiologic tests to detect an additional extracolonic malignancy. The median tipping-point for invasive follow-up occurred at a false-positive rate of 10% (IQR, 2 to >99.8%). Tipping points were significantly higher for patients than for health care professionals for both experiments (>99.8 vs 40% for radiologic follow-up and >99.8 vs 5% for invasive follow-up, both P < .001). CONCLUSION: Patients and health care professionals are willing to tolerate high rates of false-positive diagnoses with CT colonography in exchange for diagnosis of extracolonic malignancy. The actual specificity of screening CT colonography for extracolonic findings in clinical practice is likely to be highly acceptable to both patients and health care professionals. Online supplemental material is available for this article. |
| spellingShingle | Plumb, A Boone, D Fitzke, H Helbren, E Mallett, S Zhu, S Yao, G Bell, N Ghanouni, A von Wagner, C Taylor, SA Altman, D Lilford, R Halligan, S Detection of extracolonic pathologic findings with CT colonography: a discrete choice experiment of perceived benefits versus harms. |
| title | Detection of extracolonic pathologic findings with CT colonography: a discrete choice experiment of perceived benefits versus harms. |
| title_full | Detection of extracolonic pathologic findings with CT colonography: a discrete choice experiment of perceived benefits versus harms. |
| title_fullStr | Detection of extracolonic pathologic findings with CT colonography: a discrete choice experiment of perceived benefits versus harms. |
| title_full_unstemmed | Detection of extracolonic pathologic findings with CT colonography: a discrete choice experiment of perceived benefits versus harms. |
| title_short | Detection of extracolonic pathologic findings with CT colonography: a discrete choice experiment of perceived benefits versus harms. |
| title_sort | detection of extracolonic pathologic findings with ct colonography a discrete choice experiment of perceived benefits versus harms |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT plumba detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT booned detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT fitzkeh detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT helbrene detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT malletts detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT zhus detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT yaog detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT belln detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT ghanounia detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT vonwagnerc detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT taylorsa detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT altmand detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT lilfordr detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms AT halligans detectionofextracolonicpathologicfindingswithctcolonographyadiscretechoiceexperimentofperceivedbenefitsversusharms |