Randomised controlled trial of urokinase versus placebo for non-draining malignant pleural effusion
<h4>Rationale</h4> <p>Patients with malignant pleural effusion (MPE) experience breathlessness, which is treated by drainage and pleurodesis. Incomplete drainage results in residual dyspnea and pleurodesis failure. Intrapleural fibrinolytics lyse septations within pleural fluid, i...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
American Thoracic Society
2018
|
| _version_ | 1826286741838888960 |
|---|---|
| author | Mishra, E Clive, A Wills, G Davies, H Stanton, A Al-Aloul, M Hart-Thomas, A Pepperell, J Evison, M Saba, T Harrison, R Guhan, A Callister, M Sathyamurthy, R Rehal, S Corcoran, J Hallifax, R Psallidas, I Russell, N Shaw, R Dobson, M Wrightson, J West, A Lee, Y Nunn, A Miller, R Maskell, N Rahman, N |
| author_facet | Mishra, E Clive, A Wills, G Davies, H Stanton, A Al-Aloul, M Hart-Thomas, A Pepperell, J Evison, M Saba, T Harrison, R Guhan, A Callister, M Sathyamurthy, R Rehal, S Corcoran, J Hallifax, R Psallidas, I Russell, N Shaw, R Dobson, M Wrightson, J West, A Lee, Y Nunn, A Miller, R Maskell, N Rahman, N |
| author_sort | Mishra, E |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | <h4>Rationale</h4> <p>Patients with malignant pleural effusion (MPE) experience breathlessness, which is treated by drainage and pleurodesis. Incomplete drainage results in residual dyspnea and pleurodesis failure. Intrapleural fibrinolytics lyse septations within pleural fluid, improving drainage.</p> <h4>Objectives</h4> <p>To assess the effects of intrapleural urokinase on dyspnea and pleurodesis success in patients with non-draining malignant effusion.</p> <h4>Methods</h4> <p>Prospective double blind randomised trial; patients with non-draining effusion were randomly allocated 1:1 to intrapleural urokinase (100,000 IU three doses 12 hourly) or matched placebo.</p> <h4>Measurements</h4> <p>Co-primary outcome measures: dyspnea (average daily 100mm visual analogue scores over 28 days) and time to pleurodesis failure to 12 months. Secondary outcomes: survival, time in hospital and radiographic change.</p> <h4>Main results</h4> <p> 71 subjects randomised (36 received urokinase, 35 placebo) from 12 UK Centres. Baseline characteristics were similar between groups. There was no difference in mean dyspnea between groups (mean difference 3·8mm, 95% CI -12 to 4·4mm, p=0·36). Pleurodesis failure rates were similar (urokinase 13/35 (37%), placebo 11/34 (32%), adjusted hazard ratio 1·2, p=0·65). Urokinase was associated with a decreased effusion size on chest radiograph (adjusted relative improvement -19% (95% CI -28 to -11%, p<0·001), reduced hospital stay (1·6 days (95% CI 1·0 to 2·6), p=0·049) and improved survival (69 days versus 48 days, p=0.026).</p> <h4>Conclusions</h4> <p>Use of intrapleural urokinase does not reduce dyspnea or improve pleurodesis success compared with placebo, and cannot be recommended as an adjunct to pleurodesis. Other palliative treatments should be used. Improvements in hospital stay, radiographic appearance and survival associated with urokinase require further evaluation.</p> |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T01:48:14Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:992c7e6f-d10f-41d3-b38c-43bc3f1e2dfe |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T01:48:14Z |
| publishDate | 2018 |
| publisher | American Thoracic Society |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:992c7e6f-d10f-41d3-b38c-43bc3f1e2dfe2022-03-27T00:12:24ZRandomised controlled trial of urokinase versus placebo for non-draining malignant pleural effusionJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:992c7e6f-d10f-41d3-b38c-43bc3f1e2dfeEnglishSymplectic Elements at OxfordAmerican Thoracic Society2018Mishra, EClive, AWills, GDavies, HStanton, AAl-Aloul, MHart-Thomas, APepperell, JEvison, MSaba, THarrison, RGuhan, ACallister, MSathyamurthy, RRehal, SCorcoran, JHallifax, RPsallidas, IRussell, NShaw, RDobson, MWrightson, JWest, ALee, YNunn, AMiller, RMaskell, NRahman, N <h4>Rationale</h4> <p>Patients with malignant pleural effusion (MPE) experience breathlessness, which is treated by drainage and pleurodesis. Incomplete drainage results in residual dyspnea and pleurodesis failure. Intrapleural fibrinolytics lyse septations within pleural fluid, improving drainage.</p> <h4>Objectives</h4> <p>To assess the effects of intrapleural urokinase on dyspnea and pleurodesis success in patients with non-draining malignant effusion.</p> <h4>Methods</h4> <p>Prospective double blind randomised trial; patients with non-draining effusion were randomly allocated 1:1 to intrapleural urokinase (100,000 IU three doses 12 hourly) or matched placebo.</p> <h4>Measurements</h4> <p>Co-primary outcome measures: dyspnea (average daily 100mm visual analogue scores over 28 days) and time to pleurodesis failure to 12 months. Secondary outcomes: survival, time in hospital and radiographic change.</p> <h4>Main results</h4> <p> 71 subjects randomised (36 received urokinase, 35 placebo) from 12 UK Centres. Baseline characteristics were similar between groups. There was no difference in mean dyspnea between groups (mean difference 3·8mm, 95% CI -12 to 4·4mm, p=0·36). Pleurodesis failure rates were similar (urokinase 13/35 (37%), placebo 11/34 (32%), adjusted hazard ratio 1·2, p=0·65). Urokinase was associated with a decreased effusion size on chest radiograph (adjusted relative improvement -19% (95% CI -28 to -11%, p<0·001), reduced hospital stay (1·6 days (95% CI 1·0 to 2·6), p=0·049) and improved survival (69 days versus 48 days, p=0.026).</p> <h4>Conclusions</h4> <p>Use of intrapleural urokinase does not reduce dyspnea or improve pleurodesis success compared with placebo, and cannot be recommended as an adjunct to pleurodesis. Other palliative treatments should be used. Improvements in hospital stay, radiographic appearance and survival associated with urokinase require further evaluation.</p> |
| spellingShingle | Mishra, E Clive, A Wills, G Davies, H Stanton, A Al-Aloul, M Hart-Thomas, A Pepperell, J Evison, M Saba, T Harrison, R Guhan, A Callister, M Sathyamurthy, R Rehal, S Corcoran, J Hallifax, R Psallidas, I Russell, N Shaw, R Dobson, M Wrightson, J West, A Lee, Y Nunn, A Miller, R Maskell, N Rahman, N Randomised controlled trial of urokinase versus placebo for non-draining malignant pleural effusion |
| title | Randomised controlled trial of urokinase versus placebo for non-draining malignant pleural effusion |
| title_full | Randomised controlled trial of urokinase versus placebo for non-draining malignant pleural effusion |
| title_fullStr | Randomised controlled trial of urokinase versus placebo for non-draining malignant pleural effusion |
| title_full_unstemmed | Randomised controlled trial of urokinase versus placebo for non-draining malignant pleural effusion |
| title_short | Randomised controlled trial of urokinase versus placebo for non-draining malignant pleural effusion |
| title_sort | randomised controlled trial of urokinase versus placebo for non draining malignant pleural effusion |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT mishrae randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT clivea randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT willsg randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT daviesh randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT stantona randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT alaloulm randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT hartthomasa randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT pepperellj randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT evisonm randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT sabat randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT harrisonr randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT guhana randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT callisterm randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT sathyamurthyr randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT rehals randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT corcoranj randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT hallifaxr randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT psallidasi randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT russelln randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT shawr randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT dobsonm randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT wrightsonj randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT westa randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT leey randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT nunna randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT millerr randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT maskelln randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion AT rahmann randomisedcontrolledtrialofurokinaseversusplacebofornondrainingmalignantpleuraleffusion |