Dante's masterplot and the alternative narrative models in the Commedia

This thesis investigates the narrative models in Dante’s Commedia with the aim of opening up the poem to alternatives to the dominant narrative embedded in the text, which it terms Dante’s masterplot. This is the teleological trajectory which allows the poet to subjugate earlier works or earlier par...

पूर्ण विवरण

ग्रंथसूची विवरण
मुख्य लेखक: Crisafi, N
अन्य लेखक: Lombardi, E
स्वरूप: थीसिस
भाषा:English
प्रकाशित: 2018
विषय:
_version_ 1826288270565179392
author Crisafi, N
author2 Lombardi, E
author_facet Lombardi, E
Crisafi, N
author_sort Crisafi, N
collection OXFORD
description This thesis investigates the narrative models in Dante’s Commedia with the aim of opening up the poem to alternatives to the dominant narrative embedded in the text, which it terms Dante’s masterplot. This is the teleological trajectory which allows the poet to subjugate earlier works or earlier parts of the poem to the revisionist gaze of its endpoint. The thesis analyses the masterplot’s workings in the text and its role in the interpretation of the poem, and documents its overwhelming success in influencing readings of the Commedia. It then explores three competing narrative models that resist and counter its monopoly, which are enacted by (i) paradoxes, (ii) alternative endings and parallel lives; and (iii) the future. Paradoxes are used to neutralise the teleological hierarchy and thus allow Dante to represent contradictory ideas and experiences in the temporal medium of language. Through counterfactuals and twin episodes, Dante establishes in his poem a number of storylines that detour from and run parallel to the main narrative; this allows him to make room for an affective space within the text, which suspends narrative necessity and moral normativity. The future tense poses a problem case for the masterplot in that it indefinitely postpones the endpoint on which teleology relies, and thus exposes the poem, and its author’s, vulnerability to time and circumstance. By focusing on non-linear modes of storytelling, the thesis questions interpretations of the Commedia that favour one normative master-truth, and highlights instead the manifold poetic, theological and ethical tensions which, due to the masterplot’s influence, are often overlooked. The thesis concludes with a proposal that, alongside the traditional notions of Dante’s characteristic plurality of linguistic registers and styles, Dante’s narrative pluralism can and should come to play a key role in contemporary and future readings of the Commedia.
first_indexed 2024-03-07T02:11:11Z
format Thesis
id oxford-uuid:a0b2b6df-734d-4c38-97c8-58ddef7cf19a
institution University of Oxford
language English
last_indexed 2024-03-07T02:11:11Z
publishDate 2018
record_format dspace
spelling oxford-uuid:a0b2b6df-734d-4c38-97c8-58ddef7cf19a2022-03-27T02:07:19ZDante's masterplot and the alternative narrative models in the CommediaThesishttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_db06uuid:a0b2b6df-734d-4c38-97c8-58ddef7cf19aDante StudiesMedieval and Modern LanguagesItalian literatureEnglishORA Deposit2018Crisafi, NLombardi, ESoutherden, FGragnolati, MWebb, HThis thesis investigates the narrative models in Dante’s Commedia with the aim of opening up the poem to alternatives to the dominant narrative embedded in the text, which it terms Dante’s masterplot. This is the teleological trajectory which allows the poet to subjugate earlier works or earlier parts of the poem to the revisionist gaze of its endpoint. The thesis analyses the masterplot’s workings in the text and its role in the interpretation of the poem, and documents its overwhelming success in influencing readings of the Commedia. It then explores three competing narrative models that resist and counter its monopoly, which are enacted by (i) paradoxes, (ii) alternative endings and parallel lives; and (iii) the future. Paradoxes are used to neutralise the teleological hierarchy and thus allow Dante to represent contradictory ideas and experiences in the temporal medium of language. Through counterfactuals and twin episodes, Dante establishes in his poem a number of storylines that detour from and run parallel to the main narrative; this allows him to make room for an affective space within the text, which suspends narrative necessity and moral normativity. The future tense poses a problem case for the masterplot in that it indefinitely postpones the endpoint on which teleology relies, and thus exposes the poem, and its author’s, vulnerability to time and circumstance. By focusing on non-linear modes of storytelling, the thesis questions interpretations of the Commedia that favour one normative master-truth, and highlights instead the manifold poetic, theological and ethical tensions which, due to the masterplot’s influence, are often overlooked. The thesis concludes with a proposal that, alongside the traditional notions of Dante’s characteristic plurality of linguistic registers and styles, Dante’s narrative pluralism can and should come to play a key role in contemporary and future readings of the Commedia.
spellingShingle Dante Studies
Medieval and Modern Languages
Italian literature
Crisafi, N
Dante's masterplot and the alternative narrative models in the Commedia
title Dante's masterplot and the alternative narrative models in the Commedia
title_full Dante's masterplot and the alternative narrative models in the Commedia
title_fullStr Dante's masterplot and the alternative narrative models in the Commedia
title_full_unstemmed Dante's masterplot and the alternative narrative models in the Commedia
title_short Dante's masterplot and the alternative narrative models in the Commedia
title_sort dante s masterplot and the alternative narrative models in the commedia
topic Dante Studies
Medieval and Modern Languages
Italian literature
work_keys_str_mv AT crisafin dantesmasterplotandthealternativenarrativemodelsinthecommedia