Predicting alpha diversity of African rain forests: Models based on climate and satellite-derived data do not perform better than a purely spatial model
Aim Our aim was to evaluate the extent to which we can predict and map tree alpha diversity across broad spatial scales either by using climate and remote sensing data or by exploiting spatial autocorrelation patterns. Location Tropical rain forest, West Africa and Atlantic Central Africa. Methods A...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
2011
|
| _version_ | 1797086855485718528 |
|---|---|
| author | Parmentier, I Harrigan, R Buermann, W Mitchard, E Saatchi, S Malhi, Y Bongers, F Hawthorne, W Leal, M Lewis, S Nusbaumer, L Sheil, D Sosef, M Affum-Baffoe, K Bakayoko, A Chuyong, G Chatelain, C Comiskey, J Dauby, G Doucet, J Fauset, S Gautier, L Gillet, J Kenfack, D Kouamé, F |
| author_facet | Parmentier, I Harrigan, R Buermann, W Mitchard, E Saatchi, S Malhi, Y Bongers, F Hawthorne, W Leal, M Lewis, S Nusbaumer, L Sheil, D Sosef, M Affum-Baffoe, K Bakayoko, A Chuyong, G Chatelain, C Comiskey, J Dauby, G Doucet, J Fauset, S Gautier, L Gillet, J Kenfack, D Kouamé, F |
| author_sort | Parmentier, I |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | Aim Our aim was to evaluate the extent to which we can predict and map tree alpha diversity across broad spatial scales either by using climate and remote sensing data or by exploiting spatial autocorrelation patterns. Location Tropical rain forest, West Africa and Atlantic Central Africa. Methods Alpha diversity estimates were compiled for trees with diameter at breast height ≥10cm in 573 inventory plots. Linear regression (ordinary least squares, OLS) and random forest (RF) statistical techniques were used to project alpha diversity estimates at unsampled locations using climate data and remote sensing data [Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS), normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), Quick Scatterometer (QSCAT), tree cover, elevation]. The prediction reliabilities of OLS and RF models were evaluated using a novel approach and compared to that of a kriging model based on geographic location alone. Results The predictive power of the kriging model was comparable to that of OLS and RF models based on climatic and remote sensing data. The three models provided congruent predictions of alpha diversity in well-sampled areas but not in poorly inventoried locations. The reliability of the predictions of all three models declined markedly with distance from points with inventory data, becoming very low at distances >50km. According to inventory data, Atlantic Central African forests display a higher mean alpha diversity than do West African forests. Main conclusions The lower tree alpha diversity in West Africa than in Atlantic Central Africa may reflect a richer regional species pool in the latter. Our results emphasize and illustrate the need to test model predictions in a spatially explicit manner. Good OLS or RF model predictions from inventory data at short distance largely result from the strong spatial autocorrelation displayed by both the alpha diversity and the predictive variables rather than necessarily from causal relationships. Our results suggest that alpha diversity is driven by history rather than by the contemporary environment. Given the low predictive power of models, we call for a major effort to broaden the geographical extent and intensity of forest assessments to expand our knowledge of African rain forest diversity. © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T02:27:54Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:a6408843-e15b-4681-abb3-0bc01fed83bb |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T02:27:54Z |
| publishDate | 2011 |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:a6408843-e15b-4681-abb3-0bc01fed83bb2022-03-27T02:45:58ZPredicting alpha diversity of African rain forests: Models based on climate and satellite-derived data do not perform better than a purely spatial modelJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:a6408843-e15b-4681-abb3-0bc01fed83bbEnglishSymplectic Elements at Oxford2011Parmentier, IHarrigan, RBuermann, WMitchard, ESaatchi, SMalhi, YBongers, FHawthorne, WLeal, MLewis, SNusbaumer, LSheil, DSosef, MAffum-Baffoe, KBakayoko, AChuyong, GChatelain, CComiskey, JDauby, GDoucet, JFauset, SGautier, LGillet, JKenfack, DKouamé, FAim Our aim was to evaluate the extent to which we can predict and map tree alpha diversity across broad spatial scales either by using climate and remote sensing data or by exploiting spatial autocorrelation patterns. Location Tropical rain forest, West Africa and Atlantic Central Africa. Methods Alpha diversity estimates were compiled for trees with diameter at breast height ≥10cm in 573 inventory plots. Linear regression (ordinary least squares, OLS) and random forest (RF) statistical techniques were used to project alpha diversity estimates at unsampled locations using climate data and remote sensing data [Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS), normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), Quick Scatterometer (QSCAT), tree cover, elevation]. The prediction reliabilities of OLS and RF models were evaluated using a novel approach and compared to that of a kriging model based on geographic location alone. Results The predictive power of the kriging model was comparable to that of OLS and RF models based on climatic and remote sensing data. The three models provided congruent predictions of alpha diversity in well-sampled areas but not in poorly inventoried locations. The reliability of the predictions of all three models declined markedly with distance from points with inventory data, becoming very low at distances >50km. According to inventory data, Atlantic Central African forests display a higher mean alpha diversity than do West African forests. Main conclusions The lower tree alpha diversity in West Africa than in Atlantic Central Africa may reflect a richer regional species pool in the latter. Our results emphasize and illustrate the need to test model predictions in a spatially explicit manner. Good OLS or RF model predictions from inventory data at short distance largely result from the strong spatial autocorrelation displayed by both the alpha diversity and the predictive variables rather than necessarily from causal relationships. Our results suggest that alpha diversity is driven by history rather than by the contemporary environment. Given the low predictive power of models, we call for a major effort to broaden the geographical extent and intensity of forest assessments to expand our knowledge of African rain forest diversity. © 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd. |
| spellingShingle | Parmentier, I Harrigan, R Buermann, W Mitchard, E Saatchi, S Malhi, Y Bongers, F Hawthorne, W Leal, M Lewis, S Nusbaumer, L Sheil, D Sosef, M Affum-Baffoe, K Bakayoko, A Chuyong, G Chatelain, C Comiskey, J Dauby, G Doucet, J Fauset, S Gautier, L Gillet, J Kenfack, D Kouamé, F Predicting alpha diversity of African rain forests: Models based on climate and satellite-derived data do not perform better than a purely spatial model |
| title | Predicting alpha diversity of African rain forests: Models based on climate and satellite-derived data do not perform better than a purely spatial model |
| title_full | Predicting alpha diversity of African rain forests: Models based on climate and satellite-derived data do not perform better than a purely spatial model |
| title_fullStr | Predicting alpha diversity of African rain forests: Models based on climate and satellite-derived data do not perform better than a purely spatial model |
| title_full_unstemmed | Predicting alpha diversity of African rain forests: Models based on climate and satellite-derived data do not perform better than a purely spatial model |
| title_short | Predicting alpha diversity of African rain forests: Models based on climate and satellite-derived data do not perform better than a purely spatial model |
| title_sort | predicting alpha diversity of african rain forests models based on climate and satellite derived data do not perform better than a purely spatial model |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT parmentieri predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT harriganr predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT buermannw predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT mitcharde predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT saatchis predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT malhiy predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT bongersf predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT hawthornew predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT lealm predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT lewiss predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT nusbaumerl predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT sheild predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT sosefm predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT affumbaffoek predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT bakayokoa predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT chuyongg predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT chatelainc predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT comiskeyj predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT daubyg predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT doucetj predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT fausets predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT gautierl predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT gilletj predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT kenfackd predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel AT kouamef predictingalphadiversityofafricanrainforestsmodelsbasedonclimateandsatellitederiveddatadonotperformbetterthanapurelyspatialmodel |