Gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity: A response to Dewar and Weatherall
The paper investigates the status of gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity (NG), developing upon recent work by Dewar and Weatherall. The latter suggest that gravitational energy is a gauge quantity. This is potentially misleading: its gauge status crucially depends on the spacetime setting one...
| Main Authors: | , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Udgivet: |
Springer US
2019
|
| _version_ | 1826292749832290304 |
|---|---|
| author | Dürr, P Read, J |
| author_facet | Dürr, P Read, J |
| author_sort | Dürr, P |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | The paper investigates the status of gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity (NG), developing upon recent work by Dewar and Weatherall. The latter suggest that gravitational energy is a gauge quantity. This is potentially misleading: its gauge status crucially depends on the spacetime setting one adopts. In line with Møller-Nielsen’s plea for a motivational approach to symmetries, we supplement Dewar and Weatherall’s work by discussing gravitational energy–stress in Newtonian spacetime, Galilean spacetime, Maxwell-Huygens spacetime, and Newton–Cartan Theory (NCT). Although we ultimately concur with Dewar and Weatherall that the notion of gravitational energy is problematic in NCT, our analysis goes beyond their work. The absence of an explicit definition of gravitational energy–stress in NCT somewhat detracts from the force of Dewar and Weatherall’s argument. We fill this gap by examining the supposed gauge status of prima facie plausible candidates—NCT analogues of gravitational energy–stress pseudotensors, the Komar mass, and the Bel-Robinson tensor. Our paper further strengthens Dewar and Weatherall’s results. In addition, it sheds more light upon the subtle link between sufficiently rich inertial structure and the definability of gravitational energy in NG. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T03:19:30Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:b6f3b5e9-84e4-45fe-8dd6-ae2ba4afd4ac |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T03:19:30Z |
| publishDate | 2019 |
| publisher | Springer US |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:b6f3b5e9-84e4-45fe-8dd6-ae2ba4afd4ac2022-03-27T04:44:51ZGravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity: A response to Dewar and WeatherallJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:b6f3b5e9-84e4-45fe-8dd6-ae2ba4afd4acSymplectic Elements at OxfordSpringer US2019Dürr, PRead, JThe paper investigates the status of gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity (NG), developing upon recent work by Dewar and Weatherall. The latter suggest that gravitational energy is a gauge quantity. This is potentially misleading: its gauge status crucially depends on the spacetime setting one adopts. In line with Møller-Nielsen’s plea for a motivational approach to symmetries, we supplement Dewar and Weatherall’s work by discussing gravitational energy–stress in Newtonian spacetime, Galilean spacetime, Maxwell-Huygens spacetime, and Newton–Cartan Theory (NCT). Although we ultimately concur with Dewar and Weatherall that the notion of gravitational energy is problematic in NCT, our analysis goes beyond their work. The absence of an explicit definition of gravitational energy–stress in NCT somewhat detracts from the force of Dewar and Weatherall’s argument. We fill this gap by examining the supposed gauge status of prima facie plausible candidates—NCT analogues of gravitational energy–stress pseudotensors, the Komar mass, and the Bel-Robinson tensor. Our paper further strengthens Dewar and Weatherall’s results. In addition, it sheds more light upon the subtle link between sufficiently rich inertial structure and the definability of gravitational energy in NG. |
| spellingShingle | Dürr, P Read, J Gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity: A response to Dewar and Weatherall |
| title | Gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity: A response to Dewar and Weatherall |
| title_full | Gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity: A response to Dewar and Weatherall |
| title_fullStr | Gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity: A response to Dewar and Weatherall |
| title_full_unstemmed | Gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity: A response to Dewar and Weatherall |
| title_short | Gravitational energy in Newtonian Gravity: A response to Dewar and Weatherall |
| title_sort | gravitational energy in newtonian gravity a response to dewar and weatherall |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT durrp gravitationalenergyinnewtoniangravityaresponsetodewarandweatherall AT readj gravitationalenergyinnewtoniangravityaresponsetodewarandweatherall |