Challenges and lessons learned in the development of a participatory learning and action intervention to tackle antibiotic resistance: experiences from northern Vietnam
Antibiotic use in the community for humans and animals is high in Vietnam, driven by easy access to over-the counter medicines and poor understanding of the role of antibiotics. This has contributed to antibiotic resistance levels that are amongst the highest in the world. To address this problem, w...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
Frontiers Media
2022
|
| _version_ | 1797110569355968512 |
|---|---|
| author | Cai, HTN Tran, HT Nguyen, YHT Vu, GQT Tran, TP Bui, PB Nguyen, HTT Pham, TQ Lai, AT Van Nuil, JI Lewycka, S |
| author_facet | Cai, HTN Tran, HT Nguyen, YHT Vu, GQT Tran, TP Bui, PB Nguyen, HTT Pham, TQ Lai, AT Van Nuil, JI Lewycka, S |
| author_sort | Cai, HTN |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | Antibiotic use in the community for humans and animals is high in Vietnam, driven by easy access to over-the counter medicines and poor understanding of the role of antibiotics. This has contributed to antibiotic resistance levels that are amongst the highest in the world. To address this problem, we developed a participatory learning and action (PLA) intervention. Here we describe challenges and lessons learned while developing and testing this intervention in preparation for a large-scale One Health trial in northern Vietnam. We tested the PLA approach using community-led photography, and then reflected on how this approach worked in practice. We reviewed and discussed implementation documentation and developed and refined themes. Five main themes were identified related to challenges and lessons learned: understanding the local context, stakeholder relationship development, participant recruitment, building trust and motivation, and engagement with the topic of antibiotics and antimicrobial resistance (AMR). Partnerships with national and local authorities provided an important foundation for building relationships with communities, and enhanced visibility and credibility of activities. Partnership development required managing relationships, clarifying roles, and accommodating different management styles. When recruiting participants, we had to balance preferences for top-down and bottom-up approaches. Building trust and motivation took time and was challenged by limited study team presence in the community. Open discussions around expectations and appropriate incentives were re-visited throughout the process. Financial incentives provided initial motivation to participate, while less tangible benefits like collective knowledge, social connections, desire to help the community, and new skills, sustained longer-term motivation. Lack of awareness and perceived importance of the problem of AMR, affected initial motivation. Developing mutual understanding through use of common and simplified language helped when discussing the complexities of this topic. A sense of ownership emerged as the study progressed and participants understood more about AMR, how it related to their own concerns, and incorporated their own ideas into activities. PLA can be a powerful way of stimulating community action and bringing people together to tackle a common problem. Understanding the nuances of local power structures, and allowing time for stakeholder relationship development and consensus-building are important considerations when designing engagement projects. |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T07:56:38Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:d76d5f40-9357-4b77-9f5a-ff1060d609cf |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T07:56:38Z |
| publishDate | 2022 |
| publisher | Frontiers Media |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:d76d5f40-9357-4b77-9f5a-ff1060d609cf2023-08-16T12:32:50ZChallenges and lessons learned in the development of a participatory learning and action intervention to tackle antibiotic resistance: experiences from northern VietnamJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:d76d5f40-9357-4b77-9f5a-ff1060d609cfEnglishSymplectic ElementsFrontiers Media2022Cai, HTNTran, HTNguyen, YHTVu, GQTTran, TPBui, PBNguyen, HTTPham, TQLai, ATVan Nuil, JILewycka, SAntibiotic use in the community for humans and animals is high in Vietnam, driven by easy access to over-the counter medicines and poor understanding of the role of antibiotics. This has contributed to antibiotic resistance levels that are amongst the highest in the world. To address this problem, we developed a participatory learning and action (PLA) intervention. Here we describe challenges and lessons learned while developing and testing this intervention in preparation for a large-scale One Health trial in northern Vietnam. We tested the PLA approach using community-led photography, and then reflected on how this approach worked in practice. We reviewed and discussed implementation documentation and developed and refined themes. Five main themes were identified related to challenges and lessons learned: understanding the local context, stakeholder relationship development, participant recruitment, building trust and motivation, and engagement with the topic of antibiotics and antimicrobial resistance (AMR). Partnerships with national and local authorities provided an important foundation for building relationships with communities, and enhanced visibility and credibility of activities. Partnership development required managing relationships, clarifying roles, and accommodating different management styles. When recruiting participants, we had to balance preferences for top-down and bottom-up approaches. Building trust and motivation took time and was challenged by limited study team presence in the community. Open discussions around expectations and appropriate incentives were re-visited throughout the process. Financial incentives provided initial motivation to participate, while less tangible benefits like collective knowledge, social connections, desire to help the community, and new skills, sustained longer-term motivation. Lack of awareness and perceived importance of the problem of AMR, affected initial motivation. Developing mutual understanding through use of common and simplified language helped when discussing the complexities of this topic. A sense of ownership emerged as the study progressed and participants understood more about AMR, how it related to their own concerns, and incorporated their own ideas into activities. PLA can be a powerful way of stimulating community action and bringing people together to tackle a common problem. Understanding the nuances of local power structures, and allowing time for stakeholder relationship development and consensus-building are important considerations when designing engagement projects. |
| spellingShingle | Cai, HTN Tran, HT Nguyen, YHT Vu, GQT Tran, TP Bui, PB Nguyen, HTT Pham, TQ Lai, AT Van Nuil, JI Lewycka, S Challenges and lessons learned in the development of a participatory learning and action intervention to tackle antibiotic resistance: experiences from northern Vietnam |
| title | Challenges and lessons learned in the development of a participatory learning and action intervention to tackle antibiotic resistance: experiences from northern Vietnam |
| title_full | Challenges and lessons learned in the development of a participatory learning and action intervention to tackle antibiotic resistance: experiences from northern Vietnam |
| title_fullStr | Challenges and lessons learned in the development of a participatory learning and action intervention to tackle antibiotic resistance: experiences from northern Vietnam |
| title_full_unstemmed | Challenges and lessons learned in the development of a participatory learning and action intervention to tackle antibiotic resistance: experiences from northern Vietnam |
| title_short | Challenges and lessons learned in the development of a participatory learning and action intervention to tackle antibiotic resistance: experiences from northern Vietnam |
| title_sort | challenges and lessons learned in the development of a participatory learning and action intervention to tackle antibiotic resistance experiences from northern vietnam |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT caihtn challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT tranht challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT nguyenyht challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT vugqt challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT trantp challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT buipb challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT nguyenhtt challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT phamtq challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT laiat challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT vannuilji challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam AT lewyckas challengesandlessonslearnedinthedevelopmentofaparticipatorylearningandactioninterventiontotackleantibioticresistanceexperiencesfromnorthernvietnam |