Effect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children in a simulated school environment: the Back-to-School COVID-19 Simulation Randomized Clinical Trial
<p><strong>Importance</strong> Wearing a face mask in school can reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission but it may also lead to increased hand-to-face contact, which in turn could increase infection risk through self-inoculation.</p> <p><strong>Objective </strong>...
| Главные авторы: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Другие авторы: | |
| Формат: | Journal article |
| Язык: | English |
| Опубликовано: |
American Medical Association
2022
|
| _version_ | 1826309933827620864 |
|---|---|
| author | Science, M Caldeira-Kulbakas, M Parekh, RS Maguire, BR Carroll, S Anthony, SJ Bitnun, A Bourns, LE Campbell, DM Cohen, E Dodds, A Dubey, V Friedman, JN Greenwood, JL Hopkins, JP Imgrund, R Korczak, DJ Looi, T Louca, E Mertz, D Nashid, J Panzera, G Schneiderman, JE Schwartz, KL Streitenberger, L Vuppal, S Walsh, CM Jüni, P Matava, CT |
| author2 | Back-to-School COVID-19 School Study Group |
| author_facet | Back-to-School COVID-19 School Study Group Science, M Caldeira-Kulbakas, M Parekh, RS Maguire, BR Carroll, S Anthony, SJ Bitnun, A Bourns, LE Campbell, DM Cohen, E Dodds, A Dubey, V Friedman, JN Greenwood, JL Hopkins, JP Imgrund, R Korczak, DJ Looi, T Louca, E Mertz, D Nashid, J Panzera, G Schneiderman, JE Schwartz, KL Streitenberger, L Vuppal, S Walsh, CM Jüni, P Matava, CT |
| author_sort | Science, M |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | <p><strong>Importance</strong> Wearing a face mask in school can reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission but it may also lead to increased hand-to-face contact, which in turn could increase infection risk through self-inoculation.</p>
<p><strong>Objective </strong> To evaluate the effect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children while at school.</p>
<p><strong>Design, Setting, and Participants</strong> This prospective randomized clinical trial randomized students from junior kindergarten to grade 12 at 2 schools in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, during August 2020 in a 1:1 ratio to either a mask or control class during a 2-day school simulation. Classes were video recorded from 4 angles to accurately capture outcomes.</p>
<p><strong>Interventions</strong> Participants in the mask arm were instructed to bring their own mask and wear it at all times. Students assigned to control classes were not required to mask at any time (grade 4 and lower) or in the classroom where physical distancing could be maintained (grade 5 and up).</p>
<p><strong>Main Outcomes and Measures</strong> The primary outcome was the number of hand-to-face contacts per student per hour on day 2 of the simulation. Secondary outcomes included hand-to-mucosa contacts and hand-to-nonmucosa contacts. A mixed Poisson regression model was used to derive rate ratios (RRs), adjusted for age and sex with a random intercept for class with bootstrapped 95% CIs.</p>
<p><strong>Results</strong> A total of 174 students underwent randomization and 171 students (mask group, 50.6% male; control group, 52.4% male) attended school on day 2. The rate of hand-to-face contacts did not differ significantly between the mask and the control groups (88.2 vs 88.7 events per student per hour; RR, 1.00; 95% CI, 0.78-1.28; <i>P</i> = >.99). When compared with the control group, the rate of hand-to-mucosa contacts was significantly lower in the mask group (RR, 0.12; 95% CI, 0.07-0.21), while the rate of hand-to-nonmucosa contacts was higher (RR, 1.40; 95% CI, 1.08-1.82).</p>
<p><strong>Conclusions and Relevance</strong> In this clinical trial of simulated school attendance, hand-to-face contacts did not differ among students required to wear face masks vs students not required to wear face masks; however, hand-to-mucosa contracts were lower in the face mask group. This suggests that mask wearing is unlikely to increase infection risk through self-inoculation.</p>
<p><strong>Trial Registration</strong> ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT04531254</p> |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T07:44:36Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:dc3f830d-f95d-4fc2-811c-1788d0c9627c |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T07:44:36Z |
| publishDate | 2022 |
| publisher | American Medical Association |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:dc3f830d-f95d-4fc2-811c-1788d0c9627c2023-05-16T16:32:20ZEffect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children in a simulated school environment: the Back-to-School COVID-19 Simulation Randomized Clinical TrialJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:dc3f830d-f95d-4fc2-811c-1788d0c9627cEnglishSymplectic Elements American Medical Association2022Science, MCaldeira-Kulbakas, MParekh, RSMaguire, BRCarroll, SAnthony, SJBitnun, ABourns, LECampbell, DMCohen, EDodds, ADubey, VFriedman, JNGreenwood, JLHopkins, JPImgrund, RKorczak, DJLooi, TLouca, EMertz, DNashid, JPanzera, GSchneiderman, JESchwartz, KLStreitenberger, LVuppal, SWalsh, CMJüni, PMatava, CTBack-to-School COVID-19 School Study Group<p><strong>Importance</strong> Wearing a face mask in school can reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission but it may also lead to increased hand-to-face contact, which in turn could increase infection risk through self-inoculation.</p> <p><strong>Objective </strong> To evaluate the effect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children while at school.</p> <p><strong>Design, Setting, and Participants</strong> This prospective randomized clinical trial randomized students from junior kindergarten to grade 12 at 2 schools in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, during August 2020 in a 1:1 ratio to either a mask or control class during a 2-day school simulation. Classes were video recorded from 4 angles to accurately capture outcomes.</p> <p><strong>Interventions</strong> Participants in the mask arm were instructed to bring their own mask and wear it at all times. Students assigned to control classes were not required to mask at any time (grade 4 and lower) or in the classroom where physical distancing could be maintained (grade 5 and up).</p> <p><strong>Main Outcomes and Measures</strong> The primary outcome was the number of hand-to-face contacts per student per hour on day 2 of the simulation. Secondary outcomes included hand-to-mucosa contacts and hand-to-nonmucosa contacts. A mixed Poisson regression model was used to derive rate ratios (RRs), adjusted for age and sex with a random intercept for class with bootstrapped 95% CIs.</p> <p><strong>Results</strong> A total of 174 students underwent randomization and 171 students (mask group, 50.6% male; control group, 52.4% male) attended school on day 2. The rate of hand-to-face contacts did not differ significantly between the mask and the control groups (88.2 vs 88.7 events per student per hour; RR, 1.00; 95% CI, 0.78-1.28; <i>P</i> = >.99). When compared with the control group, the rate of hand-to-mucosa contacts was significantly lower in the mask group (RR, 0.12; 95% CI, 0.07-0.21), while the rate of hand-to-nonmucosa contacts was higher (RR, 1.40; 95% CI, 1.08-1.82).</p> <p><strong>Conclusions and Relevance</strong> In this clinical trial of simulated school attendance, hand-to-face contacts did not differ among students required to wear face masks vs students not required to wear face masks; however, hand-to-mucosa contracts were lower in the face mask group. This suggests that mask wearing is unlikely to increase infection risk through self-inoculation.</p> <p><strong>Trial Registration</strong> ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT04531254</p> |
| spellingShingle | Science, M Caldeira-Kulbakas, M Parekh, RS Maguire, BR Carroll, S Anthony, SJ Bitnun, A Bourns, LE Campbell, DM Cohen, E Dodds, A Dubey, V Friedman, JN Greenwood, JL Hopkins, JP Imgrund, R Korczak, DJ Looi, T Louca, E Mertz, D Nashid, J Panzera, G Schneiderman, JE Schwartz, KL Streitenberger, L Vuppal, S Walsh, CM Jüni, P Matava, CT Effect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children in a simulated school environment: the Back-to-School COVID-19 Simulation Randomized Clinical Trial |
| title | Effect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children in a simulated school environment: the Back-to-School COVID-19 Simulation Randomized Clinical Trial |
| title_full | Effect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children in a simulated school environment: the Back-to-School COVID-19 Simulation Randomized Clinical Trial |
| title_fullStr | Effect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children in a simulated school environment: the Back-to-School COVID-19 Simulation Randomized Clinical Trial |
| title_full_unstemmed | Effect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children in a simulated school environment: the Back-to-School COVID-19 Simulation Randomized Clinical Trial |
| title_short | Effect of wearing a face mask on hand-to-face contact by children in a simulated school environment: the Back-to-School COVID-19 Simulation Randomized Clinical Trial |
| title_sort | effect of wearing a face mask on hand to face contact by children in a simulated school environment the back to school covid 19 simulation randomized clinical trial |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT sciencem effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT caldeirakulbakasm effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT parekhrs effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT maguirebr effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT carrolls effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT anthonysj effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT bitnuna effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT bournsle effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT campbelldm effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT cohene effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT doddsa effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT dubeyv effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT friedmanjn effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT greenwoodjl effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT hopkinsjp effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT imgrundr effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT korczakdj effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT looit effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT loucae effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT mertzd effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT nashidj effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT panzerag effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT schneidermanje effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT schwartzkl effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT streitenbergerl effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT vuppals effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT walshcm effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT junip effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial AT matavact effectofwearingafacemaskonhandtofacecontactbychildreninasimulatedschoolenvironmentthebacktoschoolcovid19simulationrandomizedclinicaltrial |