Participatory approaches in the development of health interventions for migrants: a systematic review
<strong>Objective</strong> Analysis of participatory approaches to developing health interventions for migrants and how approaches embody core participatory principles of inclusivity and democracy. <br> <strong>Design</strong> A systematic review of original articles. E...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
BMJ Publishing Group
2021
|
| _version_ | 1797102506365419520 |
|---|---|
| author | Rustage, K Crawshaw, A Majeed-Hajaj, S Deal, A Nellums, L Ciftci, Y Fuller, SS Goldsmith, L Friedland, JS Hargreaves, S |
| author_facet | Rustage, K Crawshaw, A Majeed-Hajaj, S Deal, A Nellums, L Ciftci, Y Fuller, SS Goldsmith, L Friedland, JS Hargreaves, S |
| author_sort | Rustage, K |
| collection | OXFORD |
| description | <strong>Objective</strong> Analysis of participatory approaches to developing health interventions for migrants and how approaches embody core participatory principles of inclusivity and democracy.
<br>
<strong>Design</strong> A systematic review of original articles. Electronic searches within the databases MEDLINE, Embase, Global Health and PsychINFO (from inception—November 2020).
<br>
<strong>Eligibility criteria for study selection</strong> Original peer-reviewed articles reporting research to develop and implement a health intervention for migrants, incorporating participatory approaches. We defined migrants as foreign-born individuals. Only articles reporting the full research cycle (inception, design, implementation, analysis, evaluation, dissemination) were included.
<br>
<strong>Data extraction</strong> We extracted information related to who was involved in research (migrants or other non-academic stakeholders), the research stage at which they were involved (inception, design, implementation, analysis, evaluation, dissemination), the method of their involvement and how this aligned with the core principles of participatory research—categorising studies as exhibiting active or pseudo (including proxy and indirect) participation.
<br>
<strong>Results</strong> 1793 publications were screened, of which 28 were included in our analysis. We found substantial variation in the application of participatory approaches in designing health interventions targeting migrants: across 168 individual research stages analysed across the 28 studies, we recorded 46 instances of active participation of migrants, 30 instances of proxy participation and 24 instances of indirect participation. All studies involved non-academic stakeholders in at least one stage of the research, only two studies exhibited evidence of active participation of migrants across all research stages. Evidence is limited due to the variability of terms and approaches used.
<br>
<strong>Conclusions</strong> Important shortfalls in the meaningful inclusion of migrants in developing health interventions exist, suggesting a more rigorous and standardised approach is warranted to better define and deliver participatory research and improve quality.
<br>
<strong>Registration</strong> This review followed Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis guidelines and is registered on the Open Science Framework (osf.io/2bnz5). |
| first_indexed | 2024-03-07T06:06:56Z |
| format | Journal article |
| id | oxford-uuid:ee2a865e-a3ac-4a2f-80d1-a2fcb290f10f |
| institution | University of Oxford |
| language | English |
| last_indexed | 2024-03-07T06:06:56Z |
| publishDate | 2021 |
| publisher | BMJ Publishing Group |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | oxford-uuid:ee2a865e-a3ac-4a2f-80d1-a2fcb290f10f2022-03-27T11:30:40ZParticipatory approaches in the development of health interventions for migrants: a systematic reviewJournal articlehttp://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_dcae04bcuuid:ee2a865e-a3ac-4a2f-80d1-a2fcb290f10fEnglishSymplectic ElementsBMJ Publishing Group2021Rustage, KCrawshaw, AMajeed-Hajaj, SDeal, ANellums, LCiftci, YFuller, SSGoldsmith, LFriedland, JSHargreaves, S<strong>Objective</strong> Analysis of participatory approaches to developing health interventions for migrants and how approaches embody core participatory principles of inclusivity and democracy. <br> <strong>Design</strong> A systematic review of original articles. Electronic searches within the databases MEDLINE, Embase, Global Health and PsychINFO (from inception—November 2020). <br> <strong>Eligibility criteria for study selection</strong> Original peer-reviewed articles reporting research to develop and implement a health intervention for migrants, incorporating participatory approaches. We defined migrants as foreign-born individuals. Only articles reporting the full research cycle (inception, design, implementation, analysis, evaluation, dissemination) were included. <br> <strong>Data extraction</strong> We extracted information related to who was involved in research (migrants or other non-academic stakeholders), the research stage at which they were involved (inception, design, implementation, analysis, evaluation, dissemination), the method of their involvement and how this aligned with the core principles of participatory research—categorising studies as exhibiting active or pseudo (including proxy and indirect) participation. <br> <strong>Results</strong> 1793 publications were screened, of which 28 were included in our analysis. We found substantial variation in the application of participatory approaches in designing health interventions targeting migrants: across 168 individual research stages analysed across the 28 studies, we recorded 46 instances of active participation of migrants, 30 instances of proxy participation and 24 instances of indirect participation. All studies involved non-academic stakeholders in at least one stage of the research, only two studies exhibited evidence of active participation of migrants across all research stages. Evidence is limited due to the variability of terms and approaches used. <br> <strong>Conclusions</strong> Important shortfalls in the meaningful inclusion of migrants in developing health interventions exist, suggesting a more rigorous and standardised approach is warranted to better define and deliver participatory research and improve quality. <br> <strong>Registration</strong> This review followed Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis guidelines and is registered on the Open Science Framework (osf.io/2bnz5). |
| spellingShingle | Rustage, K Crawshaw, A Majeed-Hajaj, S Deal, A Nellums, L Ciftci, Y Fuller, SS Goldsmith, L Friedland, JS Hargreaves, S Participatory approaches in the development of health interventions for migrants: a systematic review |
| title | Participatory approaches in the development of health interventions for migrants: a systematic review |
| title_full | Participatory approaches in the development of health interventions for migrants: a systematic review |
| title_fullStr | Participatory approaches in the development of health interventions for migrants: a systematic review |
| title_full_unstemmed | Participatory approaches in the development of health interventions for migrants: a systematic review |
| title_short | Participatory approaches in the development of health interventions for migrants: a systematic review |
| title_sort | participatory approaches in the development of health interventions for migrants a systematic review |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT rustagek participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview AT crawshawa participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview AT majeedhajajs participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview AT deala participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview AT nellumsl participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview AT ciftciy participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview AT fullerss participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview AT goldsmithl participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview AT friedlandjs participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview AT hargreavess participatoryapproachesinthedevelopmentofhealthinterventionsformigrantsasystematicreview |