User Experience of Interactive Technologies for People With Dementia: Comparative Observational Study

BackgroundSerious games (SGs) are used as complementary approaches to stimulate patients with dementia. However, many of the SGs use out-of-the-shelf technologies that may not always be suitable for such populations, as they can lead to negative behaviors, such as anxiety, fatigue, and even cybersic...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Andrade Ferreira, Luis Duarte, Ferreira, Henrique, Cavaco, Sofia, Cameirão, Mónica, i Badia, Sergi Bermúdez
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: JMIR Publications 2020-08-01
Series:JMIR Serious Games
Online Access:http://games.jmir.org/2020/3/e17565/
_version_ 1818381402218954752
author Andrade Ferreira, Luis Duarte
Ferreira, Henrique
Cavaco, Sofia
Cameirão, Mónica
i Badia, Sergi Bermúdez
author_facet Andrade Ferreira, Luis Duarte
Ferreira, Henrique
Cavaco, Sofia
Cameirão, Mónica
i Badia, Sergi Bermúdez
author_sort Andrade Ferreira, Luis Duarte
collection DOAJ
description BackgroundSerious games (SGs) are used as complementary approaches to stimulate patients with dementia. However, many of the SGs use out-of-the-shelf technologies that may not always be suitable for such populations, as they can lead to negative behaviors, such as anxiety, fatigue, and even cybersickness. ObjectiveThis study aims to evaluate how patients with dementia interact and accept 5 out-of-the-shelf technologies while completing 10 virtual reality tasks. MethodsA total of 12 participants diagnosed with dementia (mean age 75.08 [SD 8.07] years, mean Mini-Mental State Examination score 17.33 [SD 5.79], and mean schooling 5.55 [SD 3.30]) at a health care center in Portugal were invited to participate in this study. A within-subject experimental design was used to allow all participants to interact with all technologies, such as HTC VIVE, head-mounted display (HMD), tablet, mouse, augmented reality (AR), leap motion (LM), and a combination of HMD with LM. Participants’ performance was quantified through behavioral and verbal responses, which were captured through video recordings and written notes. ResultsThe findings of this study revealed that the user experience using technology was dependent on the patient profile; the patients had a better user experience when they use technologies with direct interaction configuration as opposed to indirect interaction configuration in terms of assistance required (P=.01) and comprehension (P=.01); the participants did not trigger any emotional responses when using any of the technologies; the participants’ performance was task-dependent; the most cost-effective technology was the mouse, whereas the least cost-effective was AR; and all the technologies, except for one (HMD with LM), were not exposed to external hazards. ConclusionsMost participants were able to perform tasks using out-of-the-shelf technologies. However, there is no perfect technology, as they are not explicitly designed to address the needs and skills of people with dementia. Here, we propose a set of guidelines that aim to help health professionals and engineers maximize user experience when using such technologies for the population with dementia.
first_indexed 2024-12-14T02:34:00Z
format Article
id doaj.art-72e6c2d51a9b4c4ebb8a7595f0bc4411
institution Directory Open Access Journal
issn 2291-9279
language English
last_indexed 2024-12-14T02:34:00Z
publishDate 2020-08-01
publisher JMIR Publications
record_format Article
series JMIR Serious Games
spelling doaj.art-72e6c2d51a9b4c4ebb8a7595f0bc44112022-12-21T23:20:11ZengJMIR PublicationsJMIR Serious Games2291-92792020-08-0183e1756510.2196/17565User Experience of Interactive Technologies for People With Dementia: Comparative Observational StudyAndrade Ferreira, Luis DuarteFerreira, HenriqueCavaco, SofiaCameirão, Mónicai Badia, Sergi BermúdezBackgroundSerious games (SGs) are used as complementary approaches to stimulate patients with dementia. However, many of the SGs use out-of-the-shelf technologies that may not always be suitable for such populations, as they can lead to negative behaviors, such as anxiety, fatigue, and even cybersickness. ObjectiveThis study aims to evaluate how patients with dementia interact and accept 5 out-of-the-shelf technologies while completing 10 virtual reality tasks. MethodsA total of 12 participants diagnosed with dementia (mean age 75.08 [SD 8.07] years, mean Mini-Mental State Examination score 17.33 [SD 5.79], and mean schooling 5.55 [SD 3.30]) at a health care center in Portugal were invited to participate in this study. A within-subject experimental design was used to allow all participants to interact with all technologies, such as HTC VIVE, head-mounted display (HMD), tablet, mouse, augmented reality (AR), leap motion (LM), and a combination of HMD with LM. Participants’ performance was quantified through behavioral and verbal responses, which were captured through video recordings and written notes. ResultsThe findings of this study revealed that the user experience using technology was dependent on the patient profile; the patients had a better user experience when they use technologies with direct interaction configuration as opposed to indirect interaction configuration in terms of assistance required (P=.01) and comprehension (P=.01); the participants did not trigger any emotional responses when using any of the technologies; the participants’ performance was task-dependent; the most cost-effective technology was the mouse, whereas the least cost-effective was AR; and all the technologies, except for one (HMD with LM), were not exposed to external hazards. ConclusionsMost participants were able to perform tasks using out-of-the-shelf technologies. However, there is no perfect technology, as they are not explicitly designed to address the needs and skills of people with dementia. Here, we propose a set of guidelines that aim to help health professionals and engineers maximize user experience when using such technologies for the population with dementia.http://games.jmir.org/2020/3/e17565/
spellingShingle Andrade Ferreira, Luis Duarte
Ferreira, Henrique
Cavaco, Sofia
Cameirão, Mónica
i Badia, Sergi Bermúdez
User Experience of Interactive Technologies for People With Dementia: Comparative Observational Study
JMIR Serious Games
title User Experience of Interactive Technologies for People With Dementia: Comparative Observational Study
title_full User Experience of Interactive Technologies for People With Dementia: Comparative Observational Study
title_fullStr User Experience of Interactive Technologies for People With Dementia: Comparative Observational Study
title_full_unstemmed User Experience of Interactive Technologies for People With Dementia: Comparative Observational Study
title_short User Experience of Interactive Technologies for People With Dementia: Comparative Observational Study
title_sort user experience of interactive technologies for people with dementia comparative observational study
url http://games.jmir.org/2020/3/e17565/
work_keys_str_mv AT andradeferreiraluisduarte userexperienceofinteractivetechnologiesforpeoplewithdementiacomparativeobservationalstudy
AT ferreirahenrique userexperienceofinteractivetechnologiesforpeoplewithdementiacomparativeobservationalstudy
AT cavacosofia userexperienceofinteractivetechnologiesforpeoplewithdementiacomparativeobservationalstudy
AT cameiraomonica userexperienceofinteractivetechnologiesforpeoplewithdementiacomparativeobservationalstudy
AT ibadiasergibermudez userexperienceofinteractivetechnologiesforpeoplewithdementiacomparativeobservationalstudy